Complete with an advisor
Educational estimate, not insurance or actuarial advice. Not a quote, actuarial projection, legal advice, or savings guarantee. All numbers are illustrative and not actuarially validated.
Sources: claimant rates from EBRI Fast Facts #546 (2025, MarketScan 2022 data) and Sun Life high-cost claims reports (2023, 2025). Profile ranges and fit weights are still illustrative. How we built these numbers

Health Plan Risk & Return Profile

Before you choose a plan, decide how much risk feels right.

Part 1 asks how much risk your company can carry. Part 2 asks how much it could save. Like a financial-planning risk questionnaire, this matches the funding approach to what your company can carry and what it is trying to achieve.

Recommended

Quick check

Your group, claim years, the six profiles, cash flow, two quotes, a sample savings report, and a few savings and claims-data questions. Enough to show how your current setup ranks against the other arrangement types.

Full profile

Everything: risk and return, contract protections, networks, savings, data readiness, an advisor scorecard and proof.

Customize

Start with the quick check and add only the parts you care about.

How we built these numbers

Plain-English notes on where the ranges on this page come from, and what they leave out.

Next-year cost ranges

  • Each range blends a market cost trend (about 9 to 10% for 2027, in line with published employer cost-trend surveys) with the group’s own claims.
  • The share given to the group’s own claims rises with size. A carrier relies on 1,000 employees’ claims far more than on 20 employees’ claims. That is why small groups swing more.
  • Worst-case tails also draw on renewals Benefitra has seen.

By type of plan

  • Fully insured, small group: pooled with many employers, so your own claims barely move the price. 2027 Massachusetts small-group filings averaged about 10.4%.
  • Fully insured, larger group: priced partly from your own claims, around the market trend.
  • Taft-Hartley: priced for the whole multi-employer plan, using the BCBS PPO network. The official projection is about 7.5% a year.
  • PEO: the PEO’s own pool-wide increase sets the middle of the range. That increase has ranged widely, roughly 5% to 22% a year in recent years. Your group’s claims add to it, and larger groups get more weight on their own claims.
  • Captive: a layer of big-claim risk is shared with other employers, so it is steadier at small and mid sizes.
  • Level funded and self-funded: priced mostly from your own claims, with stop-loss insurance for very large ones. Ranges are set by group size.

Kinds of years and statistics

  • Year shares: good 30%, typical 45%, difficult 20%, catastrophic 5%.
  • Each renewal curve shows the median (half of renewals land below it), the mean (the average, including rare bad years) and the standard deviation (how far a typical renewal lands from the mean).
  • Each profile’s “Where this comes from” note in the comparison step gives its own source. Claimant rates come from the sources listed in the strip at the top of the page.

Time to switch

  • Lead times (quotes, underwriting, setup and open enrollment) are typical ranges by arrangement and group size, from about 1 month for small fully insured or PEO plans to about 6 months for a captive. Your real timeline is set with your Benefitra advisor.

What we don’t model

  • Individual underwriting of your group.
  • Any specific carrier’s pricing.
  • Plan design changes, such as a new deductible or a new contribution split.

Ranges are illustrative and are being reviewed by an independent actuary. Not a quote.