Funding Arrangements · Side-by-side

Seven funding paths.
One honest comparison.

Choosing how your health plan is funded matters more than choosing the carrier. The seven arrangements below trade off the same four levers, risk, cost, transparency, complexity, in different ways. This page sets them side by side.

Short answer

Every funding arrangement answers one question: who carries the claims risk. Fully-insured puts it on the carrier, self-funded puts it on you, and level-funded, captive, ICHRA, PEO and Taft-Hartley split it in different ways. Group size, claims history, workforce shape, HR capacity and state each narrow the choice. Use the side-by-side table, then request written quotes for the two or three arrangements that fit.

The risk-transfer spectrum, plainly

Every funding arrangement is an answer to one question: who bears the claims risk? On the left, the carrier owns it all (and prices it accordingly). On the right, you own it all (and capture the savings, and the bumps). The arrangements in the middle are different ways of splitting the difference.

The chart you're looking at in the background is the spectrum: red at the carrier-bears-everything end, blue at the alternative-pooling end, with the green sweet spots in the middle. Your job isn't to pick the cheapest spot. It's to pick the spot where the risk you take on is risk you can actually absorb.

Who bears the claims risk?
The carrier owns it allYou own it all
  1. Fully-InsuredCarrier
  2. Level-FundedShared (capped)
  3. CaptivePool
  4. Self-FundedYou
Risk moved to a third party
  • ICHRAEach individual
  • PEOPEO sponsor
  • Taft-HartleyTrust

Placement follows the "Who bears claims risk" row of the table below: carrier at one end, you at the other, shared or pooled risk in the middle.

Side-by-side: the seven arrangements on twelve dimensions

Same plan, same group, three different funding arrangements often produce a 30%+ cost spread over five years. The table below is what we'd want to walk a CFO through in a 30-minute strategy call. Scroll horizontally on mobile.

Dimension Fully-Insured5-30 EE Level-Funded25-150 EE Self-Funded100+ EE Captive30-100 EE ICHRAAny size PEO5-100 EE Taft-HartleyMulti-employer
Who bears claims riskCarrierShared (capped)YouPoolEach individualPEO sponsorTrust
Typical savings vs. FI—5-15%15-30%10-25%10-25%10-20%Up to 50% (high-cost states)
Year-over-year volatilityRenewal-spike riskMediumHighMedium-lowMediumLowLowest
Surplus on good yearCarrier keeps50/50 or 100%100% yoursPool-sharedUnderspend belongs to youBundled into PEPMTrust-distributed
Claims data accessLimited, delayedMonthlyReal-timeMonthly + poolPer-employee carrierLimitedTrust-level only
Plan design flexibilityCarrier templatesCustomizableFully customizableCustomizableEmployee picks own planPEO menuTrust-set
ERISA compliance burdenCarrier owns itSharedFully on youShared with captiveReduced (each employee individually insured)PEO owns itTrust owns it
Cash flow shapeFixed monthlyFixed monthlyVariable claims-as-paidFixed monthlyFixed allowance per EEFixed PEPMFixed contribution
State-mandate exposureFullPartial (depends on stop-loss)ERISA-preemptedERISA-preemptedEach plan is fully insuredFullERISA-preempted
Setup time30 days45-60 days90-120 days60-90 days45-90 days30-45 daysTrust enrollment
Admin hours / month2-44-810-206-124-81-23-6
Read the deep pageOpen →Open →Open →Open →Open →Open →Open →
Typical savings vs. fully-insuredTypical range"Up to" figure
Level-Funded5-15%
Self-Funded15-30%
Captive10-25%
ICHRA10-25%
PEO10-20%
Taft-HartleyUp to 50% (high-cost states)

From the "Typical savings vs. FI" row of the table above.

The decision framework, in five questions

There's no universal right answer, but there is a right answer for your specific group. Walk through these five questions and the funding type usually picks itself.

1 · Group size?
Under 25 EE: Fully-Insured or PEO. Below 25, level-funded math gets unstable. 25-50: Level-Funded is usually the smartest first move beyond fully-insured. 50-150: Level-Funded or Captive depending on claims stability. 150+: Self-Funded becomes worth modeling, Captive stays valid for risk-averse buyers.
2 · Claims history?
Stable (within 5% of expected for last 24 months): Level-Funded or Self-Funded, you'll capture surplus. One bad year: Captive's pool protection is worth its premium. Two consecutive bad years: Stay Fully-Insured until the trend reverses; level-funded won't help.
3 · Workforce shape?
All W-2, single state: Any traditional arrangement works. Multi-state, distributed: ICHRA often beats group plans because employees buy in their own market. 1099/W-2 mix: ICHRA for the W-2 side, contractor stipend for the rest. Unionized trades: Taft-Hartley is usually contractually obligated and provides remarkable rate stability.
4 · HR / Finance infrastructure?
No dedicated HR person: PEO bundles everything; one vendor, one bill. HR generalist + outsourced payroll: Level-Funded works. HR Director + CFO involvement: Self-Funded or Captive, these reward sophistication. Multi-state HR: ICHRA dramatically simplifies multi-state benefits.
5 · State of operation?
High-mandate state (CA, NY, MA, NJ): Self-funding (and by extension level-funded and captive) escapes some of the costliest state mandates via ERISA preemption. Worth more than the headline savings. Low-mandate state (TX, FL, TN): The state-mandate advantage shrinks; pick on cost and operational fit instead.

Open the page that fits your situation

Each arrangement has its own deep page with the full mechanics and FAQs grounded in actual employer questions. Pick where to start.

Frequently asked questions about choosing a funding arrangement

How do I choose between fully-insured, level-funded, self-funded, and captive at 75 employees?

At 75 employees, fully-insured is the most predictable option: the carrier takes the claims risk, and the premium includes the carrier's charge for carrying it. Level-funded is a common next step at this size, because you get monthly claims reports, a possible refund if claims come in under the funded amount, and stop-loss protection, without running a full self-funded plan. A captive gives you self-funded economics with part of the risk pooled with other employers. Pure self-funding needs a finance team that can handle month-to-month swings in claims. The practical test is your own claims history: if claims have tracked close to expected for two or more years, level-funded and captive quotes are worth requesting; after a very high claims year, pooling matters more than a possible refund.

Which funding arrangement has the lowest year-over-year cost volatility?

For a single employer, a Taft-Hartley trust usually has the steadiest rates, because rates are set for the whole trust rather than for your group, so one employer's bad claims year has little effect on its own. Fully-insured small-group plans come next: under the ACA, small-group premiums can vary only by age, tobacco use, geography and family size (Public Health Service Act section 2701), so a small group is not rated on its own claims. Larger fully-insured groups that are rated on their own experience can see much bigger swings at renewal. PEO plans also pool their clients. Level-funded, captive and self-funded plans reflect your own claims more directly, so they vary more by design.

What's the order I should consider funding types in as my company grows from 25 to 250 employees?

Think of it as a ladder rather than a fixed schedule, because carrier and captive size limits differ and change. Smaller groups usually start fully-insured or, where carriers offer it, level-funded. As the group grows and its claims history becomes more reliable, level-funded and captive programs become realistic. Pure self-funding generally suits larger groups with stable claims and the staff or advisers to run it. Ask each carrier or captive program for its current minimum group size rather than relying on a rule of thumb. Every step adds compliance work, so move when the numbers change, not just because you can.

Can I run two funding arrangements at once (like ICHRA + group plan)?

You can run two funding arrangements at once (like ICHRA + group plan), but only in the patterns the IRS blesses. You can put one employee class, say salaried headquarters staff, on ICHRA while another class, like hourly field crews, stays on a traditional group plan. That combination is allowed as long as the classes track the IRS categories, full-time versus part-time, salaried versus hourly, and so on. What you cannot do is split people within the same class. PEO plus ICHRA generally will not fly, because the PEO contract makes its group plan the primary offering. PEO plus Taft-Hartley does work for union shops, since those trust obligations already exist. Most multi-arrangement setups need a lawyer's eyes first, because the ERISA traps here are real.

Which funding type gives me the most claims-data transparency?

Pure self-funding gives you the most. Your TPA's reports can show claims as they are paid, by provider, diagnosis category and dollar amount, subject to HIPAA privacy rules for individual data. A self-funded captive gives you similar reporting plus pool-level figures. Level-funded plans usually send monthly claims reports after each month closes, with less immediacy. Fully-insured plans often give small groups only limited summary reports. Taft-Hartley and PEO plans report at the pool level, so what they share about your own group is thin. If transparency is the priority, the usual order is self-funded, then captive, then level-funded, then the pooled arrangements.

What does it actually cost (in admin hours per month) to manage each funding type?

There is no published standard for hours, so treat this as an order rather than a number. A PEO is usually the lightest, because it handles most administration. Fully-insured plans mostly need enrollment and employee questions. Taft-Hartley adds contribution reporting to the trust. Level-funded adds claims reconciliation, refund tracking and plan-document upkeep. ICHRA adds allowance reimbursement, verification of individual coverage and ACA reporting. A self-funded captive adds captive governance, and pure self-funding is the heaviest: reconciliation, stop-loss coordination, ERISA compliance, plan documents and fiduciary oversight. Many employers hire a TPA or consultant for the heavier ones rather than carry them in-house.

If I'm in a state with lots of healthcare regulation (CA, NY, MA), does that change which funding type is best?

A state with lots of healthcare regulation (CA, NY, MA) does change which funding type is best, in three ways. First, state benefit mandates, such as fertility or autism coverage requirements, apply to fully-insured plans but generally not to self-funded ERISA plans, because ERISA section 514 preempts state laws that relate to employee benefit plans. Second, state premium taxes, which vary by state, apply to insured premiums but not to the claims a self-funded plan pays (stop-loss premiums can still be taxed). Third, state regulators review rate increases on fully-insured plans, which can protect you from unjustified increases but can slow carrier responses. Net effect: in heavily regulated states the case for self-funded, level-funded and captive arrangements is usually stronger.

What are common reasons employers switch funding types?

Three come up often. First, renewal increases: the KFF 2025 Employer Health Benefits Survey found the average family premium rose 6% in 2025, to $26,993 a year, and individual renewals vary widely around that average. Second, claims transparency: under the ACA medical loss ratio rule, insurers must spend at least 80% of small-group premium (85% in the large-group market) on claims and quality improvement or pay rebates (45 CFR Part 158), but a fully-insured small group sees little about what drives its own claims, while level-funded plans report monthly. Third, ICHRA, which suits spread-out workforces and can be offered by employee class (the regulation lists 11 classes, 26 CFR 54.9802-4). A common mistake is moving straight from fully-insured to self-funded without trying level-funded first.

What are the seven funding arrangements compared on this page?

The page compares fully-insured, level-funded, self-funded, self-funded captive, ICHRA, PEO-integrated and Taft-Hartley arrangements. They sit on a risk-transfer spectrum: the carrier carries the risk under fully-insured coverage, you carry it under self-funding, and the others share or move it. Each has its own page with mechanics and FAQs, linked from the comparison table.

Which funding arrangement fits a group under 25 employees?

The decision framework on this page points groups under 25 employees to fully-insured coverage or a PEO, because level-funded math becomes unstable at that size. Between 25 and 50 employees, level-funded is usually the first move beyond fully-insured. Treat this as a starting point and ask each carrier for its current minimum group size, since those limits differ and change.

How should my claims history affect the choice of funding arrangement?

The framework on this page sorts groups by claims history. Stable claims over the last 24 months point toward level-funded or self-funded, where a good year produces surplus. One bad year makes a captive's pooled protection worth weighing. After two bad years in a row, staying fully-insured until the trend reverses is usually safer, because level-funded plans reflect your own claims and will not help.

How does workforce shape change which arrangement fits?

The framework on this page links workforce shape to the arrangement. An all W-2, single-state workforce can use any traditional arrangement. Multi-state or distributed teams often favor ICHRA, because employees buy coverage in their own market. A mix of 1099 contractors and W-2 employees may use ICHRA for the W-2 side. Unionized trades are often already obligated to a Taft-Hartley plan under their agreements.

Want a strategist to walk you through which path fits your group?

Send us your last 12 months of claims experience and group size, and we'll model your group across the three or four arrangements most likely to fit, with the math, the risks, and the renewal behavior of each carrier confirmed in writing.

Schedule a strategy call →

Related reading

Topic map

Start with the side-by-side table, open the arrangement pages that fit your group, then model your own numbers.

Read each arrangement

Model your group

Related guides

Reviewer: Sam Newland, CFP. Editorial policy. General information, not legal or tax advice.