Funding Arrangement · Self-Funded

Self-funded health insurance:
stop paying 25% margin to a carrier you can't see into.

Self-funding flips the script: you pay claims as they happen, hire a TPA to administer the plan, buy stop-loss to cap catastrophic risk, and keep every dollar of surplus when claims come in favorable. For 100+ EE groups with stable claims and a CFO involved in the decision, self-funded is usually the most cost-effective option in the market.

This page is the long version. If you'd rather just model your numbers: jump to the Health Funding Projector →

Best fit100+ EEStable claims, sophisticated finance team
Typical savings15 to 30%vs. fully-insured at the same plan design
Surplus on good year100% yoursNot split with carrier
Worst case (1 yr)+15 to 25%Capped by aggregate stop-loss

Short answer

A self-funded employer pays employee health claims directly, hires a TPA to run the plan and buys stop-loss insurance to cap large claims. It keeps any surplus in a good year but carries cash-flow swings, an IBNR reserve and ERISA fiduciary duties. It tends to fit larger groups with a steady claims history and a finance team that can stay with it for several years. Model your own claims before you commit.

The carrier-margin question self-funded answers most directly: "why am I paying 25-30% over actual claims to a carrier whose only contribution is bearing risk I'm sophisticated enough to bear myself?"

How self-funded actually works

You contract with a TPA (Third-Party Administrator) to process claims, manage the network, and handle ACA reporting. You buy stop-loss insurance from a reinsurer to cap your downside on catastrophic claims. You set your own plan design, what's covered, what the deductibles look like, which providers are in-network. Then you pay claims monthly as they come in.

The cash flow looks like this: each month, the TPA tells you what claims came in, you wire the funds. If a claim is over your specific stop-loss deductible (typically $250K-$500K per individual per year), the reinsurer reimburses you for the excess. At year-end, an actuarial reconciliation accounts for IBNR (Incurred But Not Reported), claims that were incurred during the plan year but haven't been billed yet. The IBNR reserve is what trips up first-year self-funded employers.

If your group's actual claims come in 15% below expected, you keep the entire 15%. If claims come in 15% above expected but below the aggregate stop-loss attachment (usually 115-125% of expected), you pay the excess. If claims breach aggregate stop-loss, the reinsurer pays, but expect a meaningful renewal increase. Self-funding rewards stable, sophisticated buyers and punishes volatile, unsophisticated ones.

What you control vs. what you don't

The defining frame for any funding decision: who owns the risk, who owns the data, who owns the surplus, who owns the compliance burden. Level-funded sits in the middle of the spectrum, more control than fully-insured, less than self-funded.

Dimension Fully-Insured Level-Funded Self-Funded
Risk on bad yearCarrier (you pay fixed)Capped at 110-125% expectedYou bear it all to stop-loss
Surplus on good yearCarrier keeps it50/50 split or 100% return100% yours
Claims data accessLimited, delayedMonthly, full detailReal-time
Plan design flexibilityCarrier templatesCustomizable within carrier frameworkFully customizable
ERISA compliance burdenCarrier owns itShared (you're the plan sponsor)Fully on you
Cash flow predictabilityFixed monthlyFixed monthlyVariable claims-as-paid
Renewal volatility5-15% typical, up to 50%Smooths over multi-yearDriven by your data

What this looks like over five years for a 75-employee group

Same group, same demographics. Self-funded shows the steepest savings curve when claims stay stable, but is the highest-volatility option of the three.

$22k $20k $18k $16k $14k Yr 1 Yr 2 Yr 3 Yr 4 Yr 5 Fully-Insured Level-Funded Self-Funded

By year 5, self-funded is the lowest-cost path, assuming claims stay within 5-10% of expected. The volatility line on this chart is honest: self-funded years 2-3 wobble (the captive and level-funded lines look smoother). That's the trade. If your CFO can absorb $100K of monthly variance to capture $300K of annual savings, self-funded works.

Where BENEFITRA actually adds value on a self-funded plan

Anyone can sell you self-funded. Here's what we do that most brokers don't:

Model your own numbers

The Health Funding Projector compares fully-insured, level-funded, self-funded, and captive across a 5-year horizon based on your group's size, location, and claims history.

Run your projection

Takes about 4 minutes. No email required for the basic projection.

Open the Health Funding Projector →

How self-funded stacks against the other six

Self-Funded is one of seven funding paths Benefitra works with. Each has a sweet spot and an exit ramp. Pick the page that matters most for your situation:

Self-funded health plans: guides, tools and where to start

A self-funded employer pays employee claims directly and buys stop-loss insurance to limit the cost of large claims. The guides below cover stop-loss contracts, captive arrangements, reference-based pricing, pharmacy costs and the filing and fiduciary duties that come with the model.

Start here

  1. See how stop-loss limits the risk: How Stop-Loss Coverage Works in Self-Funded Health Plans: The Safety Net Every Growing Company Should Understand, Stop-Loss Contract Basis: A Self-Funded Employer's Guide to Incurred and Paid Claims
  2. Test whether your group is ready: How Employers Use Claims Utilization Data to Evaluate Self-Funded Health Plan Readiness, When to Move from Fully Insured to Self-Funded Health Plans
  3. Model the cash flow and compare funding paths: Self Funded Cash Flow Analyzer, Health Funding Projector
  4. Know the warning signs before you commit: When Self-Funded Health Plans Backfire: 5 Warning Signs It's Time to Switch, When Fully Insured Is Better Than Self Funded for Small Employers

Tools and calculators

Captive plans

Moving to self-funding, administration and fiduciary duties

Reference-based pricing and cost containment

Stop-loss insurance

Calculators and tools

Pharmacy and claims data

Risk and claims trends

Reviewer: Sam Newland, CFP. Editorial policy. General information, not legal or tax advice.

Frequently asked questions about self-funded health insurance

What is IBNR liability and why does it matter at year-end on a self-funded plan?

IBNR stands for incurred but not reported: claims for care received during the plan year that had not reached your TPA when the year closed. If someone has surgery on December 28 and the hospital bills in March, that claim belongs to the old year even though the cash goes out in the new one. At year-end an actuary or your TPA estimates this liability from your claims patterns, and you hold it as a reserve. First-year self-funded employers often under-reserve because they are used to fixed fully-insured premiums. Have the estimate made before you start, fund it monthly, and settle up at year-end.

How much cash reserve should a self-funded employer hold?

There is no single rule; size the reserve with your actuary or TPA. It should cover your IBNR estimate (claims incurred but not yet paid) plus the normal month-to-month swing in claims your cash flow cannot absorb. Treat it as working capital rather than an expense. Many employers keep it in a separate account or back it with a line of credit. Stop-loss limits catastrophic claims, but it does not smooth ordinary monthly swings or the timing of reimbursements, which is what the reserve is for.

What ERISA compliance requirements come with self-funding that I don't have on fully-insured?

You are the ERISA plan administrator either way, but on a fully-insured plan the carrier supplies much of the work: the policy and certificates, claims decisions and appeals, and the insurance information (Schedule A) for Form 5500. When you self-fund, more lands on you: a written plan document, a Summary Plan Description for participants, claims and appeals decisions under ERISA's claims rules (usually run by your TPA, but the plan is responsible), Form 5500 if the plan has 100 or more participants at the start of the plan year (smaller unfunded or insured welfare plans are exempt, 29 CFR 2520.104-20), the PCORI fee (IRC 4376), ACA coverage reporting, COBRA administration if you have 20 or more employees, and HIPAA privacy and security rules for claims data, because the plan is a covered entity. A TPA or consultant can do most of the work, but the legal responsibility stays with the plan.

When does self-funding save money, and when does it not?

Self-funding tends to save the most when three things line up: the group is large enough that monthly claims even out; claims have tracked close to expected for at least two years; and the employer can stay in it for several years. Weaken any one and the savings shrink. Savings can disappear, or turn into extra cost, if the group has a lasting high-cost pattern or the stop-loss carrier lasers hard at renewal. The savings are real but conditional, so model your own claims before deciding. If your claims are not steady, a captive or level-funded plan is often a better fit.

What's the difference between a TPA and a stop-loss carrier?

A TPA runs the day-to-day. It processes claims, manages the provider network, handles enrollment and member questions, and produces your monthly claims reports, so it is who your employees deal with when a claim comes up. A stop-loss carrier is the reinsurer standing behind the plan. It does not touch individual claims; it pays you back once claims blow past your specific or aggregate deductible. Most self-funded employers hire both. Often the TPA comes bundled with a network, since Cigna, Aetna, and BCBS play that role through their ASO products, while stop-loss is bought separately from a specialty reinsurer. The two contracts renew on different clocks, carry different risks, and deserve to be negotiated as separate deals.

Can I switch back to fully-insured if self-funding doesn't work out?

You can switch back to fully-insured if self-funding doesn't work out. At renewal you end the self-funded plan and start a fully-insured one on the same day. The complication is run-out: claims incurred while you were self-funded that are billed later. Those remain your plan's responsibility after the new policy starts, so most employers pay the departing TPA to process run-out claims for a period, and check what run-out cover the stop-loss policy gives. Moving back usually means something did not work, whether high claims, the compliance load or cash-flow strain, but it is not a locked door.

What is reference-based pricing (RBP), and what's the balance-billing risk?

Reference-based pricing is a self-funded design that pays providers a set amount, usually a multiple of what Medicare pays, instead of using a negotiated network's rates. It can lower claims costs, but the exposure is balance billing: a provider that is not paid its full charge may bill the patient for the difference. For example, if a provider charges $10,000 and is paid $1,800, it may bill the patient for $8,200. The federal No Surprises Act limits balance billing for emergency care and for certain out-of-network care at in-network facilities, but it does not cover every RBP situation. An RBP plan needs an administrator that defends members against balance bills and negotiates disputes, so judge it on that support, not on the savings estimate.

Do state insurance mandates apply to a self-funded plan?

Generally, no. ERISA section 514 preempts state laws that relate to employee benefit plans, and its deemer clause stops a state from treating a self-funded plan as an insurance company. So state benefit mandates and premium taxes that apply to insured policies generally do not reach a self-funded ERISA plan. Federal rules still apply, including ERISA, HIPAA, COBRA for employers with 20 or more employees, and the ACA rules for group health plans. Stop-loss coverage is insurance, so states can regulate the stop-loss policy itself. Government and church plans are generally outside ERISA and follow different rules.

Which Affordable Care Act rules apply to a self-funded plan?

A non-grandfathered self-funded plan must follow the ACA rules for group health plans: recommended preventive care covered without cost sharing, no lifetime or annual dollar limits on essential health benefits, coverage for adult children up to age 26, the annual out-of-pocket maximum, and a waiting period of no more than 90 days. It does not have to cover the full essential health benefits package, which applies to insured individual and small-group coverage. The plan sponsor also pays the annual PCORI fee on IRS Form 720, due by July 31, and reports coverage to the IRS: on Forms 1094-C and 1095-C if the employer has 50 or more full-time employees (including equivalents), or on Forms 1094-B and 1095-B if it is smaller.

What is the difference between specific and aggregate stop-loss?

Specific stop-loss, also called individual stop-loss, reimburses the plan when one person's claims in the policy year pass a set deductible. Aggregate stop-loss reimburses the plan when the whole group's claims for the year pass a set ceiling, usually expressed as a percentage of expected claims. Many self-funded employers buy both. Before signing, check the contract basis (which incurred and paid dates count), whether the carrier can set a higher deductible for one person at renewal (known as lasering), and how renewal increases are limited. Stop-loss reimburses the plan, not employees, so the plan still owes every covered claim.

What did the Consolidated Appropriations Act add for self-funded plan sponsors?

The Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 added recurring duties that stay with the plan sponsor even when a TPA does the work. Contracts with providers, networks and administrators may not contain gag clauses that block the plan from seeing its own cost and quality data, and the plan must file a Gag Clause Prohibition Compliance Attestation with CMS by December 31 each year. The plan must also submit prescription drug and health care spending data, known as the RxDC report, by June 1 for the prior year (45 CFR 149.720). Brokers and consultants who expect $1,000 or more in direct or indirect compensation must disclose it to the plan fiduciary. Review those disclosures and keep a written record of your decisions, as our guide to self-funded fiduciary duties explains.

Can a small employer self-fund, or do state stop-loss rules get in the way?

In most states a small employer can self-fund, but each state regulates the stop-loss policy even where ERISA limits its authority over the plan itself. New York is the clearest restriction: its Department of Financial Services allows stop-loss insurance to be issued only to an employer with 101 or more full-time-equivalent employees in the prior calendar year. Other states set minimum attachment points instead. California, for example, requires a specific attachment point of at least $40,000 on small-employer stop-loss, plus an aggregate floor. Those floors set how much risk you must keep, so a policy can be legal and still be more than your cash flow can absorb. Ask which statute a quote relies on, and see our summary of state stop-loss rules for 2026.

Want a self-funded model grounded in your actual claims data?

Send us your last 24 months of claims experience and we'll model self-funded vs. captive vs. level-funded across a 5-year horizon, including the IBNR liability, reserve requirement, and stop-loss carrier comparison most brokers gloss over.

Schedule a free strategy call →

See it in practice

Related reading