Level-funded health insurance:
self-funded economics with a safety net.
See your actual claims data each month. Keep the surplus when claims are good. Stay protected by stop-loss when they aren't. For stable groups of 25-150 employees, level-funded is usually the smartest first move beyond fully-insured.
This page is the long version. If you'd rather just model your numbers: jump to the Health Funding Projector →
The carrier-margin question level-funded answers: "why am I paying 25-30% over actual claims to a carrier that won't even tell me what those claims are?"
How level-funded actually works
Every month you pay a fixed premium, just like fully-insured. But that premium isn't going into the carrier's general pool — it's split into three buckets:
- Expected claims fund (typically 70-78% of the premium): pays your group's actual medical claims as they come in. If claims run under expected, the surplus belongs to you.
- Administrative fees (6-12%): claims processing, network access, ACA reporting, plan-document maintenance.
- Stop-loss premium (12-18% combined): the reinsurance that caps your downside. Specific stop-loss limits any one person's claims; aggregate stop-loss limits the total annual claims.
At year-end the carrier reconciles. If your group's actual claims came in below the expected-claims fund, you get a refund — usually paid 90-180 days after plan-year close, sometimes as a check, sometimes credited toward next year's premium. If claims came in above expected, you don't owe more; that's what the stop-loss is for. You take the upside; the reinsurer takes the catastrophic downside. That's the whole pitch.
What you control vs. what you don't
The defining frame for any funding decision: who owns the risk, who owns the data, who owns the surplus, who owns the compliance burden. Level-funded sits in the middle of the spectrum — more control than fully-insured, less than self-funded.
| Dimension | Fully-Insured | Level-Funded | Self-Funded |
|---|---|---|---|
| Risk on bad year | Carrier (you pay fixed) | Capped at 110-125% expected | You bear it all to stop-loss |
| Surplus on good year | Carrier keeps it | 50/50 split or 100% return | 100% yours |
| Claims data access | Limited, delayed | Monthly, full detail | Real-time |
| Plan design flexibility | Carrier templates | Customizable within carrier framework | Fully customizable |
| ERISA compliance burden | Carrier owns it | Shared (you're the plan sponsor) | Fully on you |
| Cash flow predictability | Fixed monthly | Fixed monthly | Variable claims-as-paid |
| Renewal volatility | 5-15% typical, up to 50% | Smooths over multi-year | Driven by your data |
What this looks like over five years for a 75-employee group
Same group, same demographics, three funding paths. Numbers are illustrative, anchored to KFF and Mercer benchmarks for 50-99 EE groups.
By year 5, the level-funded path is roughly $3,300 per employee per year cheaper than fully-insured — about $247K/year on a 75-EE group. Self-funded is even lower if claims stay stable, but requires the cash-flow appetite and compliance infrastructure most 75-EE companies don't have. Level-funded is the bridge.
Where BENEFITRA actually adds value on a level-funded plan
Anyone can sell you level-funded. The carrier is the one taking the risk; the broker just collects the BOR. Here's what we do that most brokers don't:
- Stop-loss carrier scoring before binding. Specific deductible, aggregate attachment, laser policy at renewal, run-out coverage on plan termination — these vary widely between carriers and matter more than the headline rate. We score every carrier on five renewal-behavior metrics before recommending.
- Monthly claims reads, not quarterly. Most brokers pull your claims report once a year at renewal. We read your data monthly and flag emerging large-claimant patterns 60-90 days early, when there's still time to act.
- Honest "wrong arrangement" calls. If your claims data after Year 1 shows level-funded is the wrong fit (e.g. consistently bad claims, or strong enough that self-funded would save more), we say so — even if it means moving you off our book.
- Refund tracking. Year-end refunds are notoriously slow and easy to forget. We track every refund window, follow up with the carrier, and confirm the math against the actual claims data we already have.
What level-funded looked like for one of our clients in 2025-2026
Established stable group, 62 enrolled employees, 8 years of clean claims history, manufacturing operation outside Boston. Coming off a fully-insured PPO that hit a 14% renewal increase.
Same network, same plan design (within 1% of prior actuarial value), employees saw zero change in their experience. Renewal year 2 came in at +3.2%, vs. an industry-average 8-12% trend. This is what level-funded looks like when the group's claims are clean and the broker actually pays attention to the data.
How level-funded stacks against the other six
Level-funded is one of seven funding paths Benefitra works with. Each has a sweet spot and an exit ramp. Pick the page that matters most for your situation:
Frequently asked questions about level-funded
How do level-funded refunds actually get paid back at year-end?
At the close of the year, the carrier lines up what your group actually spent on claims against what you prepaid each month. Come in under, and you get back the unused claims fund. Many carriers split that surplus with you, often evenly, though some hand back the full amount. The money shows up 90 to 180 days after the plan year ends, either as a check or a credit toward next year. How big it runs is hard to predict: a steady group might see 5 to 12 percent, a strong year 18 to 25 percent. Go over expected and there is no refund, but there is no surprise bill either, since stop-loss absorbs the overage.
What's the difference between aggregate stop-loss and specific stop-loss in a level-funded plan?
Specific stop-loss guards you against one person blowing up. When a single claimant runs past their deductible, usually somewhere between 50,000 and 200,000 dollars in a year, the reinsurer covers everything above it. Aggregate stop-loss guards against the whole group having a bad year, kicking in when total claims cross a ceiling, typically 110 to 125 percent of what was expected. Most level-funded plans carry both. Specific is what rescues you from a single cancer case; aggregate is what rescues you when the entire group runs hot at once. Read both attachment points before you sign, because a 50,000 dollar specific deductible behaves nothing like a 200,000 dollar one.
Can a level-funded plan get more expensive than fully-insured if claims are bad?
In any single year, no. That is what the aggregate attachment is for, capping your worst case around 110 to 125 percent of expected claims. Over several years, the picture can change. A group with steadily high claims will watch its level-funded renewals climb faster than a fully-insured plan would, because fully-insured blends your risk with thousands of other groups while level-funded prices yours alone. So one rough year stays contained, but a chronic pattern eventually makes level-funded the pricier seat. Straight answer: if you have posted two years running of clearly elevated claims, level-funded is probably not your plan.
What's the minimum group size for a level-funded health plan?
Most carriers will technically write it at 5 to 10 enrolled employees, but the size where the economics actually hold up is closer to 25. Under that, your month-to-month claims bounce around so much that you spend more time leaning on stop-loss than you save on the expense load. The comfortable range sits at 50 to 150 employees: big enough for claims to even out, small enough to keep real say over plan design. If you are running 5 to 25 lives, fully-insured or a PEO usually serves you better. Once you clear 150, traditional self-funding tends to win.
How does a level-funded carrier decide my monthly premium?
Your monthly bill is stacked from four parts: expected claims, administrative fees for claims processing and network access and ACA reporting, specific stop-loss premium, and aggregate stop-loss premium. On a 50-employee group, expected claims usually make up 70 to 78 percent of the total, admin runs 6 to 12 percent, and the two stop-loss layers together land at 12 to 18 percent. Carriers set that expected-claims figure off your past 12 to 24 months of claims, your industry, your age and gender mix, and where your people live. Bring no claims history and expect them to tack on 8 to 15 percent over what the same demographics would cost with real data behind them.
What happens to my level-funded plan if a single employee has a $400K claim?
Specific stop-loss does its job. Say your specific deductible is 50,000 dollars. The first 50,000 of that person's claims comes out of your monthly claims fund like anything else. Every dollar past 50,000 belongs to the reinsurer, so a 400,000 dollar claim costs your plan 50,000, not the full amount. Everyone else's coverage rolls on untouched. The real question shows up at renewal, where that claimant might get lasered, meaning a higher deductible aimed just at them, often 100,000 to 200,000 dollars, or your whole specific level might rise. Carriers differ widely here, so Benefitra's standing advice is to get the laser policy in writing before you bind.
Why do most carriers require 12 months of claims data before quoting level-funded?
With no data, the carrier is guessing, so it defaults to worst-case assumptions for your industry and area and loads 10 to 20 percent over a quote backed by real numbers. A full year lets it see your seasonality and spot large claimants. If you are leaving a fully-insured plan, your old carrier owes you a claims experience report on request, covering the last 12 to 36 months with names redacted. Some carriers quote off as little as 6 months at a steeper load. Start a brand-new group with zero history and your realistic choices are fully-insured or a small-group product priced off ZIP and age alone, which rarely beats the fully-insured rate.
Want a level-funded quote that's actually grounded in your claims data?
Send us your last 12 months of claims experience and we'll pull stop-loss quotes from the three carriers most likely to fit your group — with the laser policy and renewal terms confirmed in writing before we present.
Schedule a free strategy call →