ICHRA:
defined contribution beats defined benefit, for the right employer.
An ICHRA (Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement) lets you set a fixed monthly allowance per employee, they go buy their own individual health plan, you reimburse up to the allowance amount tax-free. For multi-state, distributed, or W-2/1099-mixed workforces, ICHRA often beats traditional group plans on cost, flexibility, and employee satisfaction.
This page is the long version. If you'd rather just model your numbers: jump to the Health Funding Projector →
Short answer
An ICHRA lets you set a fixed monthly allowance by employee class and reimburse, tax-free, the individual health insurance or Medicare each employee chooses. It caps your spending and works at any company size, but the 2026 affordability test, county-level premiums and notice rules decide whether it fits. Employers with distributed or multi-state workforces often gain the most. Check individual-market prices in every rating area before you switch.
The defined-contribution question ICHRA answers: "why am I trying to find one health plan that fits 80 different lives across 14 states when I could give them a fixed amount and let them shop their own market?"
How ICHRA actually works
You set a monthly allowance per employee (typically $400-$1,200 per individual, more for families). Employees go to their state's individual marketplace (Healthcare.gov or state exchange) and pick a plan that fits their needs. You reimburse them up to the allowance amount on a tax-advantaged basis, the dollars never count as taxable income to the employee, and they're a deductible business expense for you.
ICHRA allows 11 IRS-defined employee classes, full-time, part-time, salaried, hourly, geography, seasonal, collective bargaining, waiting period, salaried-hourly combo, and others. You can offer different allowance amounts to different classes (e.g., $800/mo for full-time HQ staff, $500/mo for part-time field workers). You cannot discriminate within a class.
ACA affordability still applies: an ICHRA is affordable when the employee's cost of the lowest-cost silver plan for a 21-year-old in their rating area, after subtracting your monthly allowance, is no more than 9.96% of household income for 2026 (the same affordability percentage as for group plans). If your allowance is below this floor, employees aren't required to accept it, and the employer-mandate penalty triggers for groups with 50+ FTEs. ICHRA's flexibility is real, but the affordability math is unforgiving.
What you control vs. what you don't
The defining frame for any funding decision: who owns the risk, who owns the data, who owns the surplus, who owns the compliance burden. Level-funded sits in the middle of the spectrum, more control than fully-insured, less than self-funded.
| Dimension | Fully-Insured | Level-Funded | Self-Funded |
|---|---|---|---|
| Risk on bad year | Carrier (you pay fixed) | Capped at 110-125% expected | You bear it all to stop-loss |
| Surplus on good year | Carrier keeps it | 50/50 split or 100% return | 100% yours |
| Claims data access | Limited, delayed | Monthly, full detail | Real-time |
| Plan design flexibility | Carrier templates | Customizable within carrier framework | Fully customizable |
| ERISA compliance burden | Carrier owns it | Shared (you're the plan sponsor) | Fully on you |
| Cash flow predictability | Fixed monthly | Fixed monthly | Variable claims-as-paid |
| Renewal volatility | 5-15% typical, up to 50% | Smooths over multi-year | Driven by your data |
What this looks like over five years for a 75-employee group
ICHRA's cost trajectory is much flatter than group plans because allowances escalate at general inflation (3-5%) rather than medical trend (8-12%). The longer the time horizon, the bigger the gap.
By year 5, ICHRA is typically 18-24% below the group-plan trajectory because medical inflation compounds while allowances scale to general inflation. The trade: employees absorb plan-design changes year-over-year, where group plans hide that variability inside the carrier renewal.
Where BENEFITRA actually adds value on a ichra plan
Anyone can sell you ichra. Here's what we do that most brokers don't:
- Allowance design that actually clears affordability. Most employers set ICHRA allowances by gut feel and end up either overpaying or breaching the affordability floor. We model county-level lowest-cost silver pricing and recommend allowances that minimize cost while staying compliant.
- Class-structure modeling. The 11 IRS-approved employee classes can be combined in 30+ ways. We model which class structure produces the most affordable, most equitable allocation for your specific workforce.
- Employee-side support during enrollment. Most ICHRA failures come from employees not understanding the marketplace. We provide enrollment-period support, what plan to pick, how subsidies interact with ICHRA (they don't, mostly), what happens if they decline.
- Year-2 reconciliation and compliance reporting. ICHRA changes your ACA reporting cadence (1094-C and 1095-C) significantly. We handle the reconciliation and reporting so you don't get a Letter 226-J two years later.
How ichra stacks against the other six
ICHRA is one of seven funding paths Benefitra works with. Each has a sweet spot and an exit ramp. Pick the page that matters most for your situation:
ICHRA and QSEHRA: guides, tools and where to start
An individual coverage HRA (ICHRA) lets an employer set a monthly allowance and reimburse employees, tax-free, for the individual health insurance they choose. The guides below explain how an ICHRA works, how it compares with group coverage and with a QSEHRA, and how the affordability test is applied.
Start here
- Learn how an ICHRA works: Individual Coverage HRA (ICHRA): A Complete Guide for Mid-Market Employers, How Mid-Size Employers Are Using ICHRA to Give Employees Flexible Health Coverage Options in 2026
- Compare it with group coverage and a QSEHRA: ICHRA vs. Group Health Plans: What Mid-Size Employers Need to Know Before Switching, ICHRA vs QSEHRA, how the premium tax credit decides which one fits
- Check affordability and estimate the cost: ICHRA Affordability in 2026 Depends on County Math, ICHRA Calculator: Individual Coverage HRA Cost Estimator
- See what changes in the first year: ICHRA in Year One: What Mid-Size Employers Learn After Switching from Group Coverage
Tools and calculators
Affordability and the premium tax credit
- ICHRA Affordability in 2026 Depends on County Math
- ICHRA vs QSEHRA, how the premium tax credit decides which one fits
Calculator
ICHRA explained and compared
- How Mid-Size Employers Are Using ICHRA to Give Employees Flexible Health Coverage Options in 2026
- ICHRA vs. Group Health Plans: What Mid-Size Employers Need to Know Before Switching
- ICHRA in Year One: What Mid-Size Employers Learn After Switching from Group Coverage
- Individual Coverage HRA (ICHRA): A Complete Guide for Mid-Market Employers
Reviewer: Sam Newland, CFP. Editorial policy. General information, not legal or tax advice.
Frequently asked questions about ICHRA
Can I offer ICHRA to some employee classes and a group plan to others?
You can offer ICHRA to some employee classes and a group plan to others, and it is one of the reasons employers pick ICHRA. The regulation lists 11 employee classes: full-time, part-time, seasonal, employees covered by a collective bargaining agreement, employees in a waiting period, employees under age 25, non-resident aliens with no U.S.-source income, employees whose primary worksite is in the same rating area, salaried, hourly, and temporary employees of staffing firms, plus combinations of these (26 CFR 54.9802-4(d)(2)). You can put one class on ICHRA and keep another on a group plan, for example ICHRA for remote staff and a group plan for the home office. Some classes must meet a minimum class size when both are offered. Within a class the ICHRA must be offered on the same terms, except that the allowance may rise with age (up to 3 to 1) and with the number of dependents covered. Set the classes before the plan year and write them into the plan document.
How does ICHRA affordability work under ACA, what's the 9.96% threshold?
For 2026, an ICHRA counts as affordable when the employee's monthly cost for the lowest-cost silver plan for self-only coverage in their rating area, minus the monthly ICHRA allowance, is no more than 9.96% of one twelfth of household income (IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-25; 26 CFR 1.36B-2(c)(5)). If the offer is unaffordable, the employee can decline it and claim a premium tax credit instead, and an employer with 50 or more full-time employees, including equivalents, can owe an employer shared responsibility payment (IRC 4980H). The trap is geography: an allowance that passes in one county can fail in a higher-premium county, so check each rating area where you have employees.
What happens to my ACA reporting (1094-C / 1095-C) when I switch to ICHRA?
If you are an applicable large employer, you keep filing Forms 1094-C and 1095-C, but the entries change. On Form 1095-C you use the ICHRA offer codes on line 14 (a series beginning with code 1L), enter on line 15 the employee required contribution for the lowest-cost silver plan after the ICHRA allowance, and enter on line 17 the ZIP code used to find that plan (IRS Instructions for Forms 1094-C and 1095-C). Errors can lead to IRS Letter 226-J, which proposes an employer shared responsibility payment. Many employers have an ICHRA administrator prepare this reporting.
Is ICHRA cheaper than a group plan for a 75-employee company?
Sometimes. It depends on where your employees live, how your group plan has been running, and how much variation in coverage your employees will accept. Individual-market prices differ a lot by state: KFF's 2026 average benchmark silver premium for a 40-year-old ranges from $401 a month in New Hampshire to $1,299 in Vermont (KFF analysis of marketplace data). Where individual premiums are low relative to your group rates, ICHRA can cost less; where they are high, the advantage shrinks or reverses. If your group plan has had heavy claims, ICHRA's fixed allowance caps what you spend. Employees choose their own plans, so satisfaction varies. At 75 employees, compare county-level allowances with your current total cost, using the calculator on our ICHRA calculator page.
What if my employees can't find an individual plan they like in their county?
Check this before you commit. The number of marketplace insurers and plans varies widely by county, and some rural counties have only one insurer. Before you offer ICHRA, look up the actual plans for each employee's ZIP code on HealthCare.gov or your state's marketplace, confirm the main local hospital systems are in network, and confirm employees' doctors appear in at least one plan. If some employees live in counties with thin choices, you can keep them on a group plan as their own class, if the class rules allow it, and offer ICHRA to everyone else.
Can employees use ICHRA dollars for premium AND out-of-pocket costs?
Employees can use ICHRA dollars for premium AND out-of-pocket costs, depending on how you design the plan. A premium-only ICHRA reimburses the monthly premium, and the employee pays deductibles, copays and prescriptions. A broader ICHRA also reimburses qualified medical expenses up to the allowance. The broader version gives employees more room but adds work, because someone must substantiate each expense. Most ICHRA administrators handle either version, and you set the choice in the plan document before the plan year.
Does ICHRA work for 1099 contractors or only W-2 employees?
ICHRA is a W-2 tool. Under the IRS rules, a 1099 contractor is not an employee, so they cannot be on it. If your crew is mixed, you have a few moves. Offer ICHRA to your W-2 staff only, which the class rules handle cleanly. Give contractors a plain cash stipend for coverage instead, knowing it counts as taxable income to them. And take a hard look at how those contractors actually work: set hours, supervised tasks, and no outside business often mean they are misclassified, which is its own problem. ICHRA shines with an all-W-2 workforce; blended shops usually run it for one group and a stipend or nothing for the rest.
What coverage must employees have to use an ICHRA?
Each employee, and each family member the ICHRA covers, must be enrolled in individual health insurance or in Medicare (Parts A and B, or Part C) for every month the ICHRA reimburses expenses. The employer needs a reasonable way to verify that coverage, such as an attestation at enrollment and with each reimbursement request. Short-term limited-duration plans and coverage made up only of excepted benefits, such as standalone dental or vision, do not qualify. The rules are in the 2019 HRA regulations (26 CFR 54.9802-4 and the matching Department of Labor and HHS rules).
What notice must an employer give before an ICHRA starts?
A written notice to each eligible employee at least 90 days before each plan year starts. An employee who becomes eligible later, such as a new hire, must get it no later than the date they can first take part. The notice describes the allowance, the employee's right to opt out and waive future reimbursements, how the ICHRA affects premium tax credit eligibility, and the requirement to have individual coverage. The Department of Labor publishes a model notice.
What is the difference between an ICHRA and a QSEHRA?
A QSEHRA is only for employers with fewer than 50 full-time employees (including equivalents) that offer no group health plan, and the IRS caps it each year: 6,450 dollars self-only and 13,100 dollars family for 2026. It must be offered on the same terms to all eligible employees, with limited variation for age and family size. An ICHRA works at any size, has no dollar cap, and can set different allowances for defined employee classes. The two also treat the premium tax credit differently: an affordable ICHRA ends the employee's credit, while an unaffordable QSEHRA reduces it. Our ICHRA vs QSEHRA guide works through an example.
Is an ICHRA subject to ERISA and COBRA?
The ICHRA itself is an employer-sponsored group health plan, so a private employer's ICHRA is generally subject to ERISA: you need a plan document and a summary plan description, and you follow ERISA's reporting and disclosure rules. COBRA also applies to the ICHRA if you have 20 or more employees, so a departing employee may be able to continue the reimbursement arrangement for the COBRA period. The individual policies employees buy are treated differently. Under a Department of Labor safe harbor (29 CFR 2510.3-1(l)), those policies are not part of the ERISA plan if the purchase is voluntary, you do not select or endorse an insurer, you receive no payment tied to the choice, and you give employees an annual notice that the coverage is not subject to ERISA. See ICHRA in year one.
Can employees buy individual coverage outside open enrollment when an ICHRA starts?
Employees can buy individual coverage outside open enrollment when an ICHRA starts. Newly gaining access to an ICHRA is a special enrollment period trigger in the individual market under 45 CFR 155.420(d)(14), whether or not the employee was offered or enrolled in an ICHRA before. When the employer gives the required notice at least 90 days before the plan year, the employee generally has 60 days before the ICHRA's first day to choose a plan. If that early notice was not required, as with a new hire who becomes eligible mid-year, the window runs 60 days before or after. Employees leaving a group plan your company is ending may also qualify through loss of coverage. Plan the timing so individual coverage starts on the ICHRA's first day, and have your administrator help employees enroll, as described in how mid-size employers use ICHRA.
Want an ICHRA model that maps to your county-level workforce?
Send us your employee roster (de-identified) by county, and we'll model the ICHRA allowance, affordability calculation, and county-level plan availability, confirming whether ICHRA is operationally viable before you commit.
Schedule a free strategy call →