Health Plan Fit Check: are you in the right funding arrangement? About 2 minutes.

The wrong setup rarely shows up in the first-year price. It shows up in a bad year. Answer 3 quick checks: does your setup fit what you would put in, the risk you can carry, and the claims you can see and act on? If participation is low, one more check looks at affordability. You see how many checks your setup fits.

The Health Plan Fit Check

Start with risk. Price comes later.

Here is the short answer. You are likely in the right arrangement if it fits what you would put in to bring costs down, your setup fits the risk you can carry, and you can see your claims and act on them. If participation is low, your cheapest plan must also be affordable. Each check below shows a worked example first. Change the answers to see yours.

Quick check 1 of 3 · about 60 seconds

What do you have now, and does it fit?

Start with how your plan is paid for. The next questions depend on your answer.

If you’re fully insured or level funded:

Two quotes for next year. Quote 1 is the steadiest: a fixed path, and the most it can cost. Quote 2 has the lower average, with bigger swings: about 1 year in 10, it costs up to 10% more than Quote 1.

Expected yearly cost over 5 years: Quote 1 rises to $2.58M, Quote 2 to $1.97M. The shaded bar at year 1: in about 1 case in 10, Quote 2's year 1 could cost up to 10% more than Quote 1.$1.6M$1.95M$2.31M$2.66MTodayYr 1Yr 2Yr 3Yr 4Yr 51 in 10Quote 1 $2.58MQuote 2 $1.97M
Quote 1, fixed path Quote 2, expected path. Quote 2's bad case: about 1 case in 10, year 1 costs up to 10% more than Quote 1.A cheaper year 1 also lowers the base that later renewals build on, so the savings usually carry forward.
The two quotes, in dollars

Next year you have two quotes.

  • Quote 1: your cost goes up 9% (about +$151k). That is the most it can cost.
  • Quote 2: expected to cost about 8% less than Quote 1 (about $146k lower). It also tends to grow more slowly after that: if things go as expected, about $1.83M less over 5 years, and year 5 about 24% lower.
  • The catch: Quote 2 is likely, but not certain, to cost less in year 1. In about 1 case in 10, year 1 could cost up to 10% more than Quote 1 (about +$183k).
How sure would you need to be that Quote 2 costs less than Quote 1 in year 1?
If year 1 turns out to be the bad 1-in-10 year, how much more than Quote 1 could the company accept?
What matters more to you? Renewal increases compound. 7% a year adds up to about 40% by year 5, so a slower-growing cost can matter more than this year’s price.

What savings over time can look like

  1. Year 1: about 7.5%
  2. Year 2: about 13.2%
  3. Year 3: about 16.5%

Employers in one group captive saved this much compared with staying fully insured, based on that program's own 2024 study. An outside actuarial firm reviewed the method. Your results depend on your group and claims.

If you’re self-funded or in a self-funded captive:

How strong is your stop-loss contract?

Any lasers? (A higher deductible set for one person.)
A no-new-lasers guarantee at renewal?
A cap on the stop-loss renewal increase?
Aggregate corridor
Would you pay a bit more for a stronger contract?

If you’re in a PEO:

What did your PEO renewal do last year?

If you’re in a Taft-Hartley or other multiple-employer plan:

Would you take a little more risk for a lower average cost?

If you have an ICHRA:

Are employees happy with the individual plans they can buy?

Worked example: fully insured, with the assessment’s sample answers to the two-quote questions.

Worth a lookYou have: Fully insured · you’d take Quote 2 with a bad year up to 10% more

You’d take some swings for a lower average cost. Staying fully insured gives that up. A Risk & Return Assessment shows which setups fit.

On your scorecard: does not fit.

Go deeper: Is your renewal normal? The Renewal IndexHow the funding arrangements compare

Quick check 2 of 3 · about 30 seconds

Is what you have now your best fit for the risk you can carry?

A short version of the Risk & Return assessment. Rank six cost ranges with no names on them, so a label never sways you. We score you with the assessment's own rules.

Compare six profiles, then put them in your order, best on the left. Each column is one way to pay for a plan, with its name hidden. The numbers show how much your cost could change next year after each kind of claims year, for a group of about 80 enrolled. This is the same table as the full assessment.

Swipe the table sideways to see all six profiles.

Quick sort:

Most preferredLeast preferred. Column order is your ranking. Drag a column from anywhere on it (on a phone, press and hold first), use the arrow buttons, or focus a grip and press the left or right arrow key.

Six anonymous profiles compared across good, typical, difficult and catastrophic years. Column order is your ranking, from most preferred on the left.
Next-year cost change
Profile B
Profile F
Profile E
Profile D
Profile A
Profile C
Good yearBottom 30% of years
+1% to +5%
+$1.6k to +$8.3k a month
+3% to +7%
+$5k to +$12k a month
0% to +5%
$0 to +$8.3k a month
+5% to +9%
+$8.3k to +$15k a month
−4% to +4%
−$6.6k to +$6.6k a month
−9% to +2%
−$15k to +$3.3k a month
Typical yearMiddle 45%
+5% to +8%
+$8.3k to +$13k a month
+7% to +12%
+$12k to +$20k a month
+5% to +11%
+$8.3k to +$18k a month
+9% to +18%
+$15k to +$30k a month
+4% to +15%
+$6.6k to +$25k a month
+2% to +17%
+$3.3k to +$28k a month
Difficult yearNext 20%
+8% to +18%
+$13k to +$30k a month
+12% to +19%
+$20k to +$31k a month
+11% to +16%
+$18k to +$26k a month
+18% to +29%
+$30k to +$48k a month
+15% to +26%
+$25k to +$43k a month
+17% to +31%
+$28k to +$51k a month
Catastrophic yearWorst 5% (1 in 20)
+18% or more
+$30k a month or more
+19% or more
+$31k a month or more
+16% to +30% (capped)
+$26k to +$50k a month (capped)
+29% or more
+$48k a month or more
+26% or more
+$43k a month or more
+31% or more
+$51k a month or more
Renewal curveHow often each renewal happens. Navy pin and dot: average. Thick bar: typical years. Thin line: 9 years in 10. Red: 1-in-20 bad year starts, no ceiling (a solid red bar ending in a mark = hard cap). Dashed: average of all six.0+25+3%+7%+13%+18%+avg +7.5%
Where this comes from

The plan’s official projection averages about 7.5% a year. The price is set for all employers in the plan together, so your own claims matter less. A bad year across the whole plan can still bring a bigger increase. Not a quote.

0+25+5%+10%+16%+19%+avg +10.1%
Where this comes from

From Benefitra’s pricing model for your size. Larger groups are priced partly from their own claims, around the 2027 health cost trend of about 9.9%. Showing 50 to 99 enrolled. Not a quote.

0+25+3%+8%+14%+22%avg +8.2%
Where this comes from

From Benefitra’s pricing model for your size. Very big claims are shared with other employers, so a bad year moves your price less. At 40 or more enrolled, the worst case is capped at +30% (hard cap). Not a quote.

0+25+7%+14%+24%+29%+avg +14.6%
Where this comes from

From renewals we’ve seen and Benefitra’s pricing model. The average is about 13%, and more than half of groups get less. The worst 1 in 20 get +52% or more; the highest we’ve seen is +60%. Not a quote.

0+250%+10%+21%+26%+avg +9.9%
Where this comes from

Set from your own claims. Part of a good year may come back; a bad year raises next year’s price. Small groups swing most: we’ve seen a group of 4 get +133% after one $12,000 surgery. Showing 50 to 99 enrolled. Not a quote.

0+25−3%+10%+24%+31%+avg +9.9%
Where this comes from

From Benefitra’s pricing model for your size, plus renewals we’ve seen for the worst years. You keep the good years and carry the bad ones. Showing 50 to 99 enrolled. Not a quote.

Your rankColumn order
1st
2nd
3rd
4th
5th
6th

Average renewal at a glance

Rows follow your ranking. Reorder here or in the table above; both stay in step.

Quick sort:

AverageThick bar = typical years (about half)Thin line = 9 years in 10Red = 1-in-20 bad year starts here, no ceilingSolid red ending in a bar = hard capDashed = average of all six

Profile B1stavg +7.5%1-in-20 bad year: +18% or moreProfile B, ranked 1st: average renewal +7.5%; typical years +5% to +8%; 9 years in 10 +2% to +18%; 1-in-20 bad year +18% or more.
Profile F2ndavg +10.1%1-in-20 bad year: +19% or moreProfile F, ranked 2nd: average renewal +10.1%; typical years +7% to +12%; 9 years in 10 +4% to +19%; 1-in-20 bad year +19% or more.
Profile E3rdavg +8.2%1-in-20 bad year: +16% to +30% max (hard cap)Profile E, ranked 3rd: average renewal +8.2%; typical years +5% to +11%; 9 years in 10 +1% to +16%; 1-in-20 bad year +16% to +30%, a hard cap.
Profile D4thavg +14.6%1-in-20 bad year: +29% or moreProfile D, ranked 4th: average renewal +14.6%; typical years +9% to +18%; 9 years in 10 +6% to +29%; 1-in-20 bad year +29% or more.
Profile A5thavg +9.9%1-in-20 bad year: +26% or moreProfile A, ranked 5th: average renewal +9.9%; typical years +4% to +15%; 9 years in 10 −3% to +26%; 1-in-20 bad year +26% or more.
Profile C6thavg +9.9%1-in-20 bad year: +31% or moreProfile C, ranked 6th: average renewal +9.9%; typical years +2% to +17%; 9 years in 10 −7% to +31%; 1-in-20 bad year +31% or more.

Expected range based on claims of this size. Illustrative, not a quote or actuarial projection.

Drag to change the order: use a column's grip or the arrows. Put your favorite on the left. The starting order is only an example: move a column, use a sort button or choose "This order looks right".

The full Risk & Return Assessment asks 47 more questions and uses your real claims and quotes.

Worked example: fully insured today, ranked B, F, E, D, A, C (steadiest first), with the sample answers above.

Likely not your best fitYour risk profile: Moderate

Your current setup (fully insured) is likely not your best fit for a Moderate risk profile. Other arrangements fit your answers better.

You balance steady costs and long-term savings, with protections in place.

Book a 30-minute Risk & Return Assessment to see which ones, with real quotes

On your scorecard: does not fit.

See the five risk profiles
Conservative
Stable costs come first. You would give up most good-year savings to avoid surprises.
Moderately conservative
You lean toward predictable costs, with room for small swings when the savings are clear.
Moderate
You balance steady costs and long-term savings, with protections in place.
Growth-oriented
You can carry real swings to bend the cost curve, as long as the long-term savings hold up.
Aggressive
You can carry large swings and want the most control and long-term savings.

We score the 6 arrangements the assessment covers: fully insured, PEO, level funded, self-funded, self-funded captive and the Taft-Hartley plan (other multiple-employer plans are scored like it). ICHRA isn't scored here: you set an allowance and employees buy their own plans, so there is no group risk to match. Scored in your browser by the same code as our Risk & Return assessment, with its sample answers for everything not asked here. The full assessment also asks about cash flow timing, contracts and networks, so your full result can differ. Not a quote.

Go deeper: The full Risk & Return assessmentHow risk matching works

Quick check 3 of 3 · about 20 seconds

Can you see your claims and act on them?

This is how employers bring health costs down after seeing claims, without stopping anyone from getting the care they need.

Your total value from Cost Containment Programs this quarter

$202,978this quarterIllustrative sample for a group of about 500 employees. Not a real client. Your amounts scale with your plan size.
  1. See the claims
  2. Spot the chance to save
  3. Change the plan
  4. Measure the result
ProgramWhat it didThis quarter
Serious-condition coverage transition
Realized
Members with a serious, costly condition moved to individual coverage funded by a charitable program, so their claims leave the plan. $81,238
Pharmacy rebates & PBM strategy
Paid rebate + realized
Rebates paid, plus pharmacy-benefit strategies. $65,302
Medicare transition support
Realized
Helping eligible people move to Medicare. $15,889
Dialysis repricing
Realized
Dialysis claims repriced to a fair, set rate. $9,327
Cancer care support
Realized + projected
Lower cost on current cancer care, plus projected future savings. $9,320
Show all 11 programsShow top 5 only
ProgramWhat it didThis quarter
Mental health program
Estimated, study-based
Savings for engaged members, per an independent study. $5,026
Virtual primary & urgent care
Estimated
Virtual visits in place of urgent care or ER trips. $4,081
Surgical & imaging bundled rates
Realized
Planned surgery and imaging at pre-set bundled prices. $3,897
Weight management program
Estimated, study-based
Savings for engaged members, per a peer-reviewed study. $3,832
Kidney care: early intervention
Projected cost avoidance
Avoided future cost, such as an emergency dialysis start. $2,582
Kidney care: coaching
Estimated
Coaching and care coordination for kidney disease. $2,484
$184,973 (91%)Realized savings + rebates
$18,005 (9%)Projected or estimated
Program names are generic. Figures are illustrative, not a promise of savings.
Can you see your plan’s claims? (Anonymized: no employee names.)
If you answered Yes: Which of these cost containment programs do you use now? Pick any you have. Amounts are from the sample report, one quarter.If you answered No or Not sure: Based on what you know about your company’s claims, which of these could help? Pick any that fit. Amounts are from the sample report, one quarter.
If you answered Yes and use none of these: Or:

Worked example: an owner who can’t see claims and picks the 3 biggest programs.

Worth a lookYou can’t see your claims

You picked 3 programs worth $162,429 a quarter in the sample. Using them needs an arrangement where you can see claims. Fully insured and PEO plans usually don’t give you that.

On your scorecard: does not fit.

What each answer means
Yes, and you use 3 or more of the programs
You’re ahead. Now measure the results: each quarter, check what each program saved, and keep real savings apart from estimates, like the sample report does. Fits.
Yes, and you use one or two
A good start. You can see claims, so you can add more. Look at the sample report for programs that fit your claims, and measure each one every quarter. Fits.
Yes, but none yet
Seeing claims is the first step. Programs like the ones above are how employers act on them. Pick the ones that fit your claims, and measure each one every quarter. Does not fit.
Yes, but you can’t add programs
Seeing claims without being able to change the plan is common with fully insured plans. Other setups let you act on what you see. Does not fit.
No or not sure, and you pick programs
You picked 3 programs worth $162,429 a quarter in the sample. Using them needs an arrangement where you can see claims. Fully insured and PEO plans usually don’t give you that. Does not fit.

Go deeper: Cost containment programsThe sample report, explained

Extra check · about 20 seconds

Only if participation is low or affordability is a worry

Is your cheapest plan affordable for your lowest-paid worker?

The ACA has a real test. A worker's share of the cheapest employee-only plan must stay under a set share of pay: 9.96% for 2026 plan years and 10.22% for 2027 (IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-25 and Rev. Proc. 2026-26).

Worked example: 2027 plan year, lowest pay $16 an hour, worker pays $250 a month for the cheapest employee-only plan.

Not affordable$250.00 a month in 2027

The most this worker can pay for the cheapest employee-only plan in 2027: $16.00 an hour × 130 hours = $2,080.00 a month × 10.22% = $212.57 a month.

Over the IRS limit by $37.43 a month. With 50 or more full-time equivalents, an unaffordable plan can bring an ACA penalty if this worker gets subsidized coverage. Lower the employee share or change the plan.

On your scorecard: does not fit.

See the monthly limit at common pay rates
The most a worker can pay each month for the cheapest employee-only plan, rate-of-pay safe harbor: hourly rate × 130 hours × the IRS percentage.
Hourly pay2026 (9.96%)2027 (10.22%)
$15 an hour$194.22$199.29
$18 an hour$233.06$239.14
$20 an hour$258.96$265.72
$25 an hour$323.70$332.15

The penalty applies to employers with 50 or more full-time equivalents. This is one safe harbor. Payroll (Form W-2) and poverty-line safe harbors also exist. Not tax or legal advice. Want to know who would enroll at what price? A short, anonymous employee survey before quotes shows it.

Go deeper: 2027 ACA affordability percentage and payroll mathAll three affordability safe harbors

Your Health Plan Fit scorecard

How many checks does your current setup fit?

? of 3 checks fitAnswer the 3 quick checks above to fill this in.

  1. Check 1What do you have now, and does it fit? Not answered yet Does not fit if: your answer points to a different setup, or your stop-loss contract is weak or unclear.
  2. Check 2Is your setup your best fit? Not answered yet Does not fit if: your current setup is likely not your best fit for your answers.
  3. Check 3Can you see your claims and act on them? Not answered yet Does not fit if: you can’t see your plan’s claims, or you see them but use no programs or can’t act on them.
  4. Extra checkIs your cheapest plan affordable? Only if participation is low Does not fit if: your cheapest plan costs your lowest-paid worker more than the IRS limit.

Fits every check? Your setup may be right. Misses one or more? A Risk & Return Assessment shows which arrangements fit you better, with real numbers.

FAQ

Questions about the check.

Short answers, with the sources. The full picture is on our health insurance plans guide.

How do I know if I am in the right health plan funding arrangement?

Run the Health Plan Fit Check. Three checks: does what you have now fit how much you would put in to bring costs down (or, if you self-fund, is your stop-loss contract strong)? Does your setup match the risk you can carry? Can you see your plan’s claims and act on them? A fourth check counts only if fewer than 70% of eligible staff enroll or some struggle to afford coverage: is your cheapest plan affordable for your lowest-paid worker? You see how many checks your setup fits. If it misses one or more, a Risk & Return Assessment shows which arrangements fit you better.

Is my health insurance renewal increase normal?

For 2 to 50 employees (up to 100 in California, New York and Vermont), compare it with your state's Benefitra Renewal Index. We call it normal up to the Index plus 4.4 points, the Index's typical miss, high up to twice that, and a red flag above. In Texas the Index is 11.27%, so normal is up to 15.7% and a red flag is over 20.1%. Larger groups have no public filings, so we use our fully insured ranges: typical up to +12%, and 1 year in 20 starts at +19%.

How do I know how much health plan risk my company can take?

Rank six cost ranges without names, the core step of the Risk & Return assessment. The assessment's own code turns that into one of five risk profiles, from Conservative to Aggressive, and tells you if what you have now is likely your best fit. In our worked example, fully insured is likely not the best fit for a Moderate profile. A Risk & Return Assessment shows which arrangements fit better, with real quotes.

Should my health plan show me where my claims dollars went?

This plan provides the Massachusetts tax document showing that you have health insurance. You can't cut costs you can't see. A good report comes every quarter, shows what each program saved, and keeps real savings apart from estimates. Our sample quarterly report shows $202,978 in one quarter for a group of about 500 employees. It is an illustrative sample, not a real client.

What is the ACA affordability percentage for 2026 and 2027?

For plan years starting in 2026 it is 9.96% (IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-25). For 2027 it is 10.22% (IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26). Under the rate-of-pay safe harbor, the cheapest employee-only plan is affordable if the worker's monthly share is no more than that percentage of their hourly rate times 130 hours. At $16 an hour in 2027, that is $212.57 a month.

What should I do if my setup misses a check?

Book a Risk & Return Assessment. Bring your last renewal. An advisor runs the full model on your real claims and renewals, so you see your good, typical and worst years, your written limits, and which arrangements and quotes are worth getting. You can also try the full test on your own first.

Missed a check? Find out what fits.

Bring your last renewal. In a Risk & Return Assessment we run the full model with you: your limits, your options and each one's bad year.