In this article 12 sections
- What the group plan costs you in 2027
- What employees face on the marketplace and with enhanced premium tax credits in 2027
- Why the raise has to be bigger than the premium
- The make-whole raise by age and pay
- The $63,840 cliff in practice
- Above the cliff, the state sets the bill
- Families below the cliff can come out ahead
- A 20-person example
- What the model leaves out
- Rules that apply when you drop
- Open enrollment options before you cancel
- Five checks before you decide
Plenty of owners are asking the question this fall. In an eHealth survey published September 16, 2026, 73% of small and mid-sized employers offering group coverage said they are considering dropping it for 2027. Cost was the main reason for 85% of them. The usual plan is simple: cancel the group policy, give everyone a raise, and let employees buy their own coverage on the marketplace.
Whether that saves money depends on one thing most articles skip. It depends on where each employee's household income sits against the 2027 premium tax credit rules. We ran the numbers with 2027 marketplace premiums, the 2027 subsidy table, 2027 tax brackets and Benefitra's 50-state small group rate filings. The answer swings from "dropping saves thousands" to "dropping costs three times your current premium share" inside the same 20-person company.
What the group plan costs you in 2027
Start with what you would stop paying. KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, published October 22, 2026, puts the average small firm (10 to 199 workers) premium at $9,593 for single coverage and $27,288 for family coverage. Workers pay 16% of the single premium and $9,687 of the family premium on average.
Benefitra tracks the 2027 small group rate filing in all 50 states. The median change is 12.8%. Apply it to the KFF averages and keep the 2026 split:
| 2027 at the median 12.8% | Single | Family |
|---|---|---|
| Total premium | $10,818 | $30,771 |
| Employee pays | $1,731 | $10,924 |
| Employer pays | $9,087 | $19,848 |
So the money on the table is about $9,087 per single employee and $19,848 per family. That is the most the employer can save per person by dropping. Every dollar of raise, and the payroll tax on it, comes out of that.
What employees face on the marketplace and with enhanced premium tax credits in 2027
The individual market is not cheaper ground. KFF's state data shows the average benchmark silver premium for a 40-year-old at $497 a month in 2025, $625 in 2026 and $703 in 2027, and insurers proposed a median premium increase of 15% for 2027. KFF's November 6 open enrollment brief puts the two-year rise at 42% on average. By state, the 2027 figure runs from $486 in New Hampshire to $1,313 in Vermont.
We compared that with our small group filings. The median state benchmark rose 13.3% for 2027, against 12.8% for small group. In 29 of 50 states the individual benchmark rose faster than the small group filing. Moving employees to the marketplace does not get them away from rising premiums. ACA Marketplace enrollment fell by about 3 million in 2026. That is a problem for marketplace enrollees trying to manage monthly premiums through the ACA Marketplace.
Age matters far more on the marketplace. Under the CMS default age curve, a 60-year-old is rated at 2.714 against 1.278 for a 40-year-old. At the national average that turns $703 a month into $1,493, or $17,915 a year. Your group plan already prices age, but the employer pays most of it. On the ACA plans side, the employee does, unless the subsidy steps in. A bronze plan may offer a lower monthly premium, but it often comes with a higher deductible and more cost sharing; about 40% of enrollees chose these low-cost options in 2026, and the average deductible was about $7,500. That can mean much higher out of pocket costs, with an out of pocket maximum that may exceed $30,000 in 2027, while a catastrophic plan can leave an individual facing about $12,000 before most coverage begins.
The enhanced premium tax credits expired at the end of 2025 and had not been restored for 2027 as of November 5, 2026. That brings back the 400% cliff. For 2027 coverage, using the 2026 HHS poverty guidelines, the line is $63,840 for a single person and $132,000 for a family of four. A lower premium can look attractive on the ACA marketplace enrollment screen, but lower premium choices in aca plans can still raise out of pocket costs through heavier cost sharing.
Why the raise has to be bigger than the premium
Employer premiums are tax-free to the employee. A raise is not. It carries 7.65% in employee FICA plus income tax, 12% federal for a single filer with taxable income up to $52,025 in 2027 and 22% above it. The employer pays its own 7.65% FICA on the raise too. The employee's old payroll deduction was pre-tax through a Section 125 plan. Once the plan ends, that money becomes taxable pay again, and the employer pays FICA on it.
The raise also has to be a plain raise. IRS Notice 2015-17 says extra pay that is not conditioned on buying health coverage is not an employer payment plan. If you reimburse or pay individual premiums directly outside an ICHRA or QSEHRA, the IRS treats it as a group health plan that fails the market reforms. That can mean a $100 per day excise tax per employee under section 4980D.
The make-whole raise by age and pay
We define the make-whole raise as the smallest raise that leaves a single employee with the same after-tax cash, after paying for a benchmark silver plan, as staying on the group plan and paying $1,731. Federal income tax and FICA are included, state income tax is not. Here are the results at the national average premium:
| Single employee | Age 30 | Age 40 | Age 60 | Employer result per person |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Earns $40,000 | $3,300 | $3,300 | $3,300 | Saves $5,402 |
| Earns $55,000 | $6,040 | $6,040 | $6,040 | Saves $2,452 |
| Earns $70,000 | $8,870 | $10,220 | $23,690 | Loses $594, $2,047 and $16,548 by age |
The first two rows show the part of the subsidy most people miss. Below 400% of the poverty line, the premium tax credit caps the employee's benchmark cost at a share of income, 10.22% at the top of the table. The government pays the rest. So the raise is the same for a 30-year-old and a 60-year-old. We also ran the $55,000 worker in all 50 states, and the answer was $6,040 in every one. Age and state stop mattering.
The third row is where it changes. At $70,000 a single worker is above the cliff, pays full price, and the employer loses money on the 40-year-old and badly on the 60-year-old.
The $63,840 cliff in practice
The cliff is sharper than most owners expect, because the raise itself can push someone over it.
| Single, age 60 | Make-whole raise | Income after raise |
|---|---|---|
| Earns $57,000 | $6,330 | $63,330 |
| Earns $58,000 | $21,980 | $79,980 |
A $1,000 difference in pay creates a $15,650 difference in the raise. At $58,000, any raise small enough to stay under $63,840 still leaves the employee short, so the only way to make them whole is a raise big enough to cover the full premium. At the national average, a 60-year-old earning $63,840 pays $6,524 a year for the benchmark plan. Earn $10 more and the bill is $17,915.
How much credit is lost at that line depends on the state. For a single 60-year-old, the median across 50 states is $10,817. It is $5,861 in New Hampshire and $24,565 in Alaska, where higher poverty guidelines move the line to $79,800.
Two things blunt the cliff. A traditional pre-tax 401(k) deferral lowers the income used for the credit, so some employees can stay under the line. And the test is household income, not wages. A $55,000 worker married to someone earning $50,000 is over the family line already, and your payroll records won't show it. That brings back the 400% cliff tied to the federal poverty level.

Above the cliff, the state sets the bill
Once a worker is over the line, once subsidy eligibility ends, the price of a marketplace plan or new plan in that state drives the make-whole raise. For a single employee earning $70,000, here is the make-whole raise in a few states, using KFF's 2027 benchmark and the CMS default age curve:
| State | Age 60 benchmark per year | Make-whole raise, age 60 at $70,000 |
|---|---|---|
| New Hampshire | $12,385 | $15,830 |
| Maryland | $12,512 | $16,010 |
| California | $16,131 | $21,150 |
| North Carolina | $16,819 | $22,130 |
| Georgia | $18,679 | $24,780 |
| Texas | $18,781 | $24,920 |
| Florida | $18,807 | $24,960 |
| Wyoming | $30,325 | $41,330 |
Employers should compare plans carefully before assuming a cheaper individual option exists. The median across 50 states is $22,870. In all 50, the raise for this employee is more than the $9,087 the employer stops paying. For a 40-year-old at $70,000, the raise costs more than the employer's share in 41 of 50 states.
Families below the cliff can come out ahead
Family coverage works the other way for many households. A family of four with two 40-year-old parents and two young children faces a national average benchmark of $26,971 a year in 2027. On the group plan, the same family pays $10,924.
Some families trying to save money may choose a lower monthly premium option, but about 40% of ACA enrollees opted for bronze plans with high deductibles, which can leave people pay more when they actually use care; once group coverage ends, some households may no longer afford richer coverage.
| Family of four, household income | Result if the employer drops coverage |
|---|---|
| $60,000 | $5,445 better off with no raise |
| $85,000 | $1,215 better off with no raise |
| $110,000 | Needs a $3,520 raise |
| $125,000 | Needs a $5,710 raise |
| $140,000 | Needs a $26,260 raise |
At $60,000 and $85,000, the credit is worth more than the employer's family contribution. Some of these families may already qualify for marketplace help for the spouse and children, because family members are measured on the cost of family coverage. Our 2027 contribution guide shows where those income lines fall.
A 20-person example
Take 12 single and 8 family enrollees, the same mix we used for the contribution example. The singles are three 30-year-olds at $40,000, three 40-year-olds at $55,000, two 45-year-olds at $70,000, two 60-year-olds at $55,000 and two 60-year-olds at $70,000. Four families earn $85,000, two earn $110,000 and two earn $125,000.
The employer's 2027 premium share is $267,823. Dropping the plan and paying every make-whole raise costs $147,659, including employer FICA. On paper the company saves $120,164.
Look at who gets the money, though. Employees losing coverage often end up in plans with higher out-of-pocket costs and narrower networks, even when the employer saves money overall. The two 60-year-olds earning $70,000 need $47,380 between them, 37% of all the raises. These are usually the senior people the business depends on. Four of the families need nothing. The savings come almost entirely from federal subsidies replacing the employer's contribution for lower-paid staff.

What the model leaves out
The numbers above are the most favorable case for dropping. Six things can push the real cost higher:
- Plan value. The comparison uses a benchmark silver plan. Many small group plans have lower deductibles, so a like-for-like individual plan costs more.
- Payroll-linked costs. A raise also raises 401(k) matches, workers' compensation premiums and anything else priced on payroll.
- Household income you can't see. A spouse's pay can put an employee over the cliff.
- State tax. We left out state income tax, which makes every raise larger.
- Permanence. A raise is hard to take back. A group plan can be changed every year.
- Policy risk. The subsidy rules can change by law, and your raise does not change with them.
Rules that apply when you drop
If you have fewer than 50 full-time employees, including equivalents, no federal penalty applies. Larger employers owe the 2027 4980H(a) penalty of $3,780 per full-time employee, minus the first 30, once any full-time employee claims a premium tax credit. Our employer penalty guide walks through it.
When the employer stops offering any group health plan, COBRA coverage ends too (26 CFR 54.4980B-7). Losing employer coverage is a qualifying event that opens a marketplace Special Enrollment Period, which starts 60 days before the loss and runs 60 days after (45 CFR 155.420). If employees miss that 60-day window, they usually must wait for the next open enrollment. Short-term insurance may be available if they miss open enrollment. Give employees notice early enough to use the 60 days before.
Open enrollment options before you cancel
Dropping is not the only way to cut the 2027 bill. During renewal season, small employers often revisit benefits because of steep premium increases and administrative burdens. Many employers making a change are moving away from traditional group plans without eliminating coverage entirely.
- Change the funding. KFF found 38% of covered workers at smaller firms are already in level-funded plans. Run your group through the funding simulator and see the 2027 filing for your state on our state funding pages.
- Change the split. Protecting single coverage and sharing the family increase costs much less than most owners expect, and because group health insurance remains a key recruitment and retention tool, cutting it can hurt competitive talent acquisition.
- Use an HRA. A QSEHRA or ICHRA keeps the employer money tax-free, though an affordable offer can block the employee's credit if employer sponsored coverage costs more than about 9% of annual income or covers less than 60% of costs. Our ICHRA vs QSEHRA guide explains how, and employers that drop group plans may need higher salaries or stipends to attract talent.
Five checks before you decide
- List each enrolled employee's age, pay and coverage tier.
- Mark everyone within about $6,000 of the $63,840 single line or the family line for their household size.
- Price the benchmark silver plan for each employee's age and county on the ACA Marketplace, then compare plans across available ACA plans while weighing monthly premiums against cost sharing and out of pocket costs.
- Work out the make-whole raise for your most senior people first, since they set the real cost.
- Compare the total with a level-funded quote and a contribution change for the same January 1 date.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to drop traditional group health insurance and give employees a raise in 2027?
It can be, but the answer depends on whether employees can get affordable coverage through the ACA Marketplace after losing coverage from employer sponsored coverage. Many employers do not eliminate benefits entirely; some move to level-funded arrangements instead of having workers lose coverage. It is usually more expensive for anyone over the 400% line, especially older workers. In our 20-person example the employer saved $120,164, but two senior employees needed 37% of all the raises.
How big a raise does an employee need if I drop coverage?
At the 2027 national average, a single employee earning $55,000 needs about $6,040 to stay whole after federal tax, at any age. A 60-year-old earning $70,000 needs about $23,690. The figures assume a benchmark silver plan and leave out state income tax.
Can I pay my employees' individual health insurance premiums instead of a group plan?
Only through an ICHRA or a QSEHRA. Paying or reimbursing individual premiums any other way is an employer payment plan, which can trigger a $100 per day excise tax per employee under section 4980D. A taxable raise that is not tied to buying coverage is allowed.
What is the 400% poverty line for 2027 marketplace subsidies?
For 2027 coverage it is $63,840 for one person and $132,000 for a family of four in the 48 contiguous states and DC, measured against the federal poverty level for the household size. Above that household income there is no premium tax credit, because the enhanced credits expired at the end of 2025, though catastrophic eligibility can also depend on an affordability exemption for some people outside the usual subsidy ranges.
Do employees get COBRA if the employer cancels the group plan?
They do not. COBRA ends when the employer stops offering any group health plan. Workers can get free help with the enrollment process from certified counselors or assisters on the federal government platform, who can help compare plans and answer a coverage question during ACA Marketplace enrollment. Some state marketplaces, such as Covered California, offer similar support and more resources for people shopping after a loss of coverage. Employees can use the loss of coverage special enrollment period, which starts 60 days before coverage ends.
Sources
- eHealth, Survey: 54% of Small- to Mid-Sized Businesses Report Double-Digit Health Plan Premium Increases for 2027, September 16, 2026, https://s204.q4cdn.com/837903328/files/doc_news/Survey-54-of-Small--to-Mid-Sized-Businesses-Report-Double-Digit-Health-Plan-Premium-Increases-for-2027-2026.pdf
- KFF, 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, October 22, 2026, https://www.kff.org/health-costs/2026-employer-health-benefits-survey/
- KFF State Health Facts, Marketplace Average Benchmark Premiums (2025 to 2027), accessed November 12, 2026, https://www.kff.org/affordable-care-act/state-indicator/marketplace-average-benchmark-premiums/
- KFF, 9 Things to Watch for the 2027 ACA Open Enrollment Period, November 6, 2026, https://kff.org/affordable-care-act/9-things-to-watch-for-the-2027-aca-open-enrollment-period/
- Internal Revenue Service, Revenue Procedure 2026-26 (2027 applicable percentage table), 2026, https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-26-26.pdf
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Annual Update of the HHS Poverty Guidelines, Federal Register, January 15, 2026, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00755/annual-update-of-the-hhs-poverty-guidelines
- Internal Revenue Service, IRS releases tax inflation adjustments for tax year 2027 (IR-2026-133, Rev. Proc. 2026-35), November 5, 2026, https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/irs-releases-tax-inflation-adjustments-for-tax-year-2027-taxpayers-continue-to-benefit-from-the-working-families-tax-cuts
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Final Guidance Regarding Age Curves and State Reporting, December 16, 2016, https://www.cms.gov/cciio/resources/regulations-and-guidance/downloads/final-guidance-regarding-age-curves-and-state-reporting-12-16-16.pdf
- Internal Revenue Service, Notice 2015-17, February 2015, https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-15-17.pdf
- Internal Revenue Service, Employer Health Care Arrangements, accessed November 12, 2026, https://www.irs.gov/affordable-care-act/employer-health-care-arrangements
- Internal Revenue Service, Revenue Procedure 2026-22 (2027 section 4980H amounts), 2026, https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-26-22.pdf
- Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 26 CFR 54.4980B-7, accessed November 12, 2026, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/54.4980B-7
- Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 45 CFR 155.420, accessed November 12, 2026, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/155.420
- Benefitra, 2027 state health insurance funding analysis (small group filed and final rates), accessed November 12, 2026, https://benefitra.com/health-insurance-funding/
