Insurance Strategy

How to Split a 2027 Small Group Increase With Employees

Photo of Sam Newland, CFP® Sam Newland, CFP® Published Last reviewed Reviewed by Sam Newland, CFP (editorial policy) 13 min read
Small business owners reviewing 2027 health insurance renewal figures and deciding the employee contribution split

January 1, 2027 renewals are being signed now, and for most small employers, employee health insurance contribution 2027 decisions come down to a 12.8% median small-group premium increase and a choice that can raise a typical single employee contribution by about $196 a year or by as much as $1,225, depending on how you split the cost. If you run a company with roughly 20 to 250 employees, or you lead HR or finance through renewal season, the renewal tells you the new premium, but it does not tell you who should pay it.

Most owners start with one of four answers: keep today's percentages, absorb the whole increase, pass the whole increase on, or protect one tier and share the other. Each choice moves real dollars, changes whether single and family coverage stay affordable, and can affect employee morale, dependent eligibility for premium tax credits, and enrollment. Below are the numbers for each, built from KFF's 2026 small firm data and Benefitra's 2027 rate filings for all 50 states, along with the 2027 federal affordability rules and the funding-method questions that shape what employers should set for contributions.

Where small employers start in 2026

The KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey, published October 22, 2026, gives the clearest starting point. For firms with 10 to 199 workers, the averages look like this:

2026, small firms (10 to 199 workers) Single coverage Family coverage
Total annual premium $9,593 $27,288
Average worker contribution rate 16% 37%
Average worker contribution in dollars about $1,535 $9,687
Employer share in dollars about $8,058 about $17,601

KFF reports the family dollar figure directly. The single dollar figure is 16% of the single premium, so treat it as an estimate.

Two things in the 2026 survey stand out. Small employers are generous on single coverage, but average annual premiums for family coverage reached $28,303 in 2026, up 5%, and contributions kept rising. 29% of covered workers at smaller firms pay nothing for it, compared with 5% at larger firms. They are much less generous on family coverage. 32% of covered workers at smaller firms pay more than half of the family premium, and 31% already pay $12,000 or more a year for it. At larger firms, workers pay 25% of the family premium. At smaller firms they pay 37%.

So most small employers walk into 2027 with a cheap single tier and an expensive family tier. The split you choose for 2027 either keeps that shape or makes it sharper.

What 2027 adds to those health insurance premiums

Benefitra tracks the 2027 small group rate filing for every state. Across 50 states the median change is 12.8%. It runs from 3.7% requested in Mississippi to 20.6% requested in North Carolina. 38 states are at 10% or more and 19 are at 15% or more. 17 of the 50 are final and 33 are still requested. KFF's August 2026 review of 295 small group insurers found a median requested increase of 14%, so the two sources tell a similar story. Rising health insurance premiums also reflect provider consolidation and inflation pushing up unit costs for procedures and services, while high-cost specialty medications keep lifting baseline plan expenses. Regulatory factors add about 1% more pressure, and Aon projects a 9.5% increase in U.S. employer healthcare costs for 2027, the fifth straight year of above-trend growth. Many employers are responding through plan design changes and cost shifting; about 59% are exploring moves such as raising deductibles.

Premium 2026 2027 at 12.8% 2027 at 20.6%
Single $9,593 $10,818 (+$1,225) $11,564 (+$1,971)
Family $27,288 $30,771 (+$3,483) $32,896 (+$5,608)

These are averages for members who stay the same age. Your own renewal is usually a few points higher, because every employee moves up a year on the age curve. We showed how that works in why your 2027 renewal exceeds the filed rate. Run the splits below on your own renewal numbers, not on the state average.

Four ways to split the increase

Every contribution decision for 2027 is a version of one of these four:

  1. Hold the split. Employer and employees keep the same percentages as 2026, so both shares rise by the full rate increase.
  2. Employer absorbs it. Employee dollar contributions stay flat for every tier. The company pays the whole increase.
  3. Employees absorb it. The employer's dollar contribution stays flat (a defined contribution). Employees pay the whole increase.
  4. Protect single, share family. Single contributions stay flat in dollars. The family tier keeps its 2026 percentage split.

The fourth option is the one most renewal guides skip, and for many small groups it is the one that fits.

What each split costs at the median 12.8%

Here are the per-person numbers, using the KFF 2026 averages and the 12.8% median. Note that the family worker share in the KFF dollar averages works out to 35.5%, not the 37% average rate. That is because KFF averages the rates and the dollar amounts separately.

Split Single, worker pays Single, employer pays Family, worker pays Family, employer pays
Hold the split $1,731 (+$196) $9,087 (+$1,029) $10,924 (+$1,237) $19,848 (+$2,247)
Employer absorbs $1,535 (+$0) $9,283 (+$1,225) $9,687 (+$0) $21,084 (+$3,483)
Employees absorb $2,760 (+$1,225) $8,058 (+$0) $13,170 (+$3,483) $17,601 (+$0)
Protect single, share family $1,535 (+$0) $9,283 (+$1,225) $10,924 (+$1,237) $19,848 (+$2,247)

Employees feel these numbers per paycheck. On a biweekly payroll, holding the split adds $7.54 per check for single coverage and $47.56 for family. Passing the whole increase on adds $47.12 per check for single and $133.97 for family.

At the 20.6% high end, the gaps get wider. If employees absorb it, the family contribution reaches $15,295 a year, or 46.5% of the premium. The single contribution goes from $1,535 to $3,506, more than double.

A 20-person example

Take a company with 20 enrolled employees, 12 on single coverage and 8 on family, at the KFF average premiums. In 2026 the employer pays $237,504 a year toward the plan. Here is the added employer cost for 2027 at 12.8%:

Split Added employer cost in 2027 Employer total for 2027
Employees absorb $0 $237,504
Hold the split $30,317 $267,821
Protect single, share family $32,669 $270,173
Employer absorbs $42,561 $280,065

The gap between holding the split and protecting single is $2,352 a year, or $196 for each of the 12 single employees. For that amount, nobody on single coverage sees a higher deduction in 2027. The family tier carries the same percentage it did in 2026.

Fully absorbing the increase costs $9,892 more than the hybrid. Almost all of that extra goes to family contributions.

Why the single tier deserves protection

There is a regulatory reason, not just a morale reason. If your company is an applicable large employer (50 or more full-time employees, counting equivalents, or 50 or more full time equivalent employees), your coverage must be affordable under the employer mandate. For plan years beginning in calendar year 2027, the IRS set the affordability threshold at 10.22%, up from 9.96% in 2026, in Revenue Procedure 2026-26.

Many employers use the federal poverty line safe harbor because it needs no payroll data. In the mainland United States, the affordability calculation applies to the lowest-cost self only coverage the employer must offer coverage on, and it caps the 2027 monthly employee charge at $135.93. The 2026 cap was $129.90. The average small firm single contribution in 2026 was about $127.92 a month, just under that line. Hold the split at 12.8% and it becomes $144.25 a month, which is over the 2027 cap. Protect the single tier and it stays at $127.92.

Two caveats. The KFF average includes the 29% of workers who pay nothing, so the average for employees who do pay something is higher, and closer to the line. And the poverty line method is only one of three safe harbors. The rate of pay method allows more for most workers. Our 2027 ACA affordability guide has the payroll tables.

Employers under 50 have no affordability test, but they do have a contribution floor. Most small group carriers set a minimum employer share of the employee-only premium, often 50%. Federal rules let a carrier nonrenew a group that falls below it (45 CFR 147.106(b)(3)). The small business health care tax credit also requires at least 50% of the employee-only premium. If you cut your single contribution, check those numbers first.

The family tier and the $12,000 line

The family tier is where the money is, and where the risk of losing enrollment is highest. Under the employees absorb split, the average family contribution goes from $9,687 to $13,170. Even holding the split takes it to $10,924. Since 31% of small firm workers with family coverage already pay $12,000 or more, a pass-through puts a large share of them past that figure.

Employee and spouse reviewing the cost of family health coverage at home after a 2027 contribution increase

A higher family contribution also changes what the employee's family can buy elsewhere. Since the Treasury's October 2022 rule on family member affordability, a spouse and children are measured on the employee's cost for family coverage, not single coverage. If that cost exceeds 10.22% of household income in 2027, the family members are treated as not having affordable employer coverage. They can then qualify for a marketplace premium tax credit, if they meet the other income and eligibility rules.

Here is where that line falls for each split:

Family worker contribution Household income below which family members fail the 10.22% test
$9,687 (2026 level, held flat) $94,785
$10,924 (hold the split) $106,888
$13,170 (employees absorb) $128,865

Moving dependents to the marketplace can be a good outcome for some families. For your plan it means fewer enrolled members and, in some cases, a participation problem at the next renewal. Ask your carrier in writing how it counts employees who waive coverage and how it counts dependents who leave. Our 2027 special enrollment period guide covers participation minimums and the November 15 to December 15 window.

Pre-tax deductions for high deductible health plans soften the shift

If employee contributions run through a Section 125 premium only plan, employees can use pre tax dollars for health insurance premiums, which lowers taxable income for both employees and the employer before income tax and FICA. Employers also often review flexible spending accounts, including a health FSA, during open enrollment because those elections affect payroll setup and employee health expenses. Each dollar moved to employees then costs them less than a dollar, and the employer saves its 7.65% FICA share on it. For the $1,237 family increase under a held split, FICA alone saves the employee $94.63 and the employer the same amount. With flexible spending, unused funds above any allowed rollover can be forfeited. Income tax savings depend on each employee's bracket. A plan document is required, so if you take contributions out of pay after tax today, fix that before January.

Employer weighing how much of the 2027 health insurance premium increase to pass to employees

When the split is the wrong question

If your renewal is in the high teens or above, no split makes it comfortable. Even a held split adds $40,000 or more to the employer cost for a 20-person group, and a full pass-through raises family contributions by $4,600 to $5,600. At that point the useful question is whether fully insured is still the right funding method.

Small employers are already moving. KFF's 2026 survey found that 38% of covered workers at smaller firms are in a level-funded plan. KFF's 2027 rate review notes that the fully insured small group market has shrunk from about 17 million covered lives in 2013 to about 10 million, as healthier groups left. Some employer offers now pair lower-premium high deductible health plans with a health savings account, which can change the contribution conversation rather than just shifting premium costs across health plans. For an hsa qualified plan, 2027 contribution limits are $4,500 for self only coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, and workers 55 or older can add $1,000 for qualified medical expenses. For high deductible health, the 2027 individual floor is a $1,750 minimum deductible with an $8,700 out-of-pocket maximum, distinct from the broader ACA caps of $12,000 self-only and $24,000 family. In our 2027 funding simulator runs, level funding beat staying fully insured over five years in a median of 91% of simulated outcomes for 30-employee groups (47 states) and 81% for 10-employee groups (46 states). That is not a promise for any one group. A group with a known high cost claimant may do better staying in the community rated pool. The full comparison is in level funded vs fully insured for 2027 renewals, and our state funding pages show the 2027 filing for your state.

Six checks before you send the 2027 contribution sheet

  1. Put your own 2026 and 2027 premiums by tier into the four splits above, not the state average, and finalize 2027 choices before open enrollment closes for the new plan year.
  2. If you have 50 or more full-time employees, test the lowest cost self-only option for eligible employees using the applicable safe harbor at the full-time employee level.
  3. Confirm your single contribution still meets the carrier's minimum employer share, and the 50% tax credit rule if you claim it.
  4. Work out the family contribution as a share of the household incomes typical in your workforce, using the table above.
  5. Ask the carrier in writing how waivers and departing dependents count toward participation.
  6. During open enrollment, employees can change, keep, or decline health plans and other benefits for the upcoming plan year. For calendar-year plans, this usually happens late in the prior calendar year, so update enrollment materials and communicate contribution changes clearly to active employees, COBRA participants, and employees on leave; employers must also offer open enrollment rights under COBRA.
  7. Confirm that contributions are deducted pre-tax under a Section 125 plan document.

For more on setting contribution levels across tiers over the long run, see our contribution strategy guide.

Frequently asked questions

Should I pass the 2027 health insurance increase on to employees?

Passing all of it on usually adds about $1,225 a year to a typical single contribution and $3,483 to a family contribution at the median 12.8% increase. Many small employers protect single coverage and share the family increase instead. In our 20-person example that costs only $2,352 a year more than keeping the current percentages.

How much do small employers contribute to health insurance in 2026?

KFF's 2026 survey shows that employer contributions cover a substantial share of employee-only premiums at most employers: workers at firms with 10 to 199 employees pay 16% of the single premium and 37% of the family premium on average, while family contributions vary more widely. The family contribution averages $9,687 a year. 29% of these workers pay nothing for single coverage.

Does a higher employee contribution make my plan unaffordable under the ACA affordability percentage?

Only applicable large employers, those with 50 or more full-time employees, face the affordability test and must offer coverage that is affordable and provides minimum value to avoid potential penalties. For 2027, the limit is 10.22% of income for the lowest cost self-only plan, meaning the employee's required contribution is tested against a percentage of the employee's household income, though employers usually rely on safe harbors because they do not know an employee's household income. Under the poverty line safe harbor that is $135.93 a month in the mainland United States.

Can raising family contributions make my employees' families eligible for marketplace subsidies?

It can. Family members are measured on the employee's cost for family coverage. If that cost exceeds 10.22% of household income in 2027, the spouse and children may qualify for a premium tax credit if they meet the other eligibility rules. The employee stays tied to the employer plan if single coverage is affordable.

Is there a minimum amount a small employer has to contribute?

Federal law does not require employers to make a specific contribution amount toward small-group health coverage, although other rules may still require employers to offer qualifying coverage or meet carrier contribution floors depending on size and market. Most small group carriers require a minimum share of the employee-only premium, often 50%, and can nonrenew a group that falls below it. The small business health care tax credit also requires at least 50% of the employee-only premium.

Sources

  1. KFF, 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, October 22, 2026, https://www.kff.org/health-costs/2026-employer-health-benefits-survey/
  2. Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, How much and why premiums are going up for small businesses in 2027, August 6, 2026, https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/brief/how-much-and-why-premiums-are-going-up-for-small-businesses-in-2027/
  3. Internal Revenue Service, Revenue Procedure 2026-26, July 2026, https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rp-26-26.pdf
  4. U.S. Department of the Treasury and Internal Revenue Service, Affordability of Employer Coverage for Family Members of Employees (final regulations), Federal Register, October 13, 2022, https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/13/2022-22184/affordability-of-employer-coverage-for-family-members-of-employees
  5. Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 45 CFR 147.106, Guaranteed renewability of coverage, accessed November 5, 2026, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/147.106
  6. Internal Revenue Service, Small Business Health Care Tax Credit and the SHOP Marketplace, accessed November 5, 2026, https://www.irs.gov/affordable-care-act/employers/small-business-health-care-tax-credit-and-the-shop-marketplace
  7. Benefitra, 2027 state health insurance funding analysis (small group filed and final rates, funding simulator results), accessed November 5, 2026, https://benefitra.com/health-insurance-funding/
  8. Benefitra, 2027 ACA Affordability Percentage and Payroll Math, August 18, 2026, https://benefitra.com/2027-aca-affordability-percentage/
Sam Newland, CFP®

About the Author

Sam Newland, CFP® is the Founder and President of Benefitra. With 13+ years in the employee benefits industry and a background as a nationally recognized benefits advisor, Sam specializes in helping mid-size employers identify the funding strategies, plan structures, and tax optimization approaches that reduce costs without cutting coverage. He can be reached at sam@benefitra.com.

Related Benefitra Tools