Insurance Strategy

Why Your 2027 Small Group Renewal Exceeds the Filed Rate

Photo of Sam Newland, CFP® Sam Newland, CFP® Published Last reviewed Reviewed by Sam Newland, CFP (editorial policy) 13 min read
Small business owner reading a 2027 small group health insurance renewal and comparing it with the filed rate

Renewal letters for January 1, 2027 are landing now. If you're looking up the 2027 small group renewal increase, the short answer is that your actual renewal will often run higher than the filed state average, typically around 16% or more, not 12.8%, because every employee ages one year on the age curve, your carrier may map you to a different plan, and renewals after January can pick up a quarterly factor.

A lot of owners and HR or Finance leaders at companies with roughly 20 to 250 employees have read a headline number for their state, opened their own renewal, and found it several points higher. They assume the carrier rated them up for claims. In a small group plan under 50 employees, that usually isn't what happened. Federal rules don't let a small group carrier price your group on its own claims.

The gap almost always comes from three mechanical items that the published average leaves out on purpose. Below, I'll show you how to read the filed rate, check the age impact, spot plan mapping changes and renewal timing adjustments, and compare those mechanics to your own notice so you can verify the increase, avoid surprises, and make better funding or plan decisions before renewal is final.

What the filed rate actually measures in group health insurance

Each small group carrier files one set of rates per state for its whole single risk pool. The number that reaches the news is a weighted average across that carrier's renewing members, or the people enrolled. Rhode Island's insurance commissioner states plainly what it includes. In its June 2026 summary of requested 2027 small group rates, the Office of the Health Insurance Commissioner says the overall weighted average "represents the average rate change consumers will experience before changes due to age."

Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Georgia's 2027 small group actuarial memorandum, filed May 26, 2026, makes the same point from the other direction. It reports an average increase of 7.1%, with individual plans ranging from 6.5% to 8.3%, and states: "No changes in age or other demographic characteristics are projected."

So the published figure answers a narrow question about the filed premium increase. If the same person, at the same age, stays on a typical plan, how much does the price move? Your renewal answers a different one.

Where 2027 filings landed by state

Benefitra tracks the small group filing for every state and updates it as states move from requested to final rates. Across all 50 states, the median filed 2027 change is 12.8%. As of today, 17 states have final rates and 33 are still at the requested stage. Those filings can help employers estimate a likely renewal increase before their own paperwork arrives. The Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, working from 295 insurer filings, put the median requested increase at 14%, with 59% of small group insurers asking for between 10% and 20%. By comparison, ACA plans saw a median proposed premium increase of 15%.

State 2027 small group change Status
North Carolina 20.55% Requested
Arizona 19.87% Requested
West Virginia 19.69% Requested
Texas 18.94% Requested
New Jersey 18.46% Requested
Median, 50 states 12.77% Mixed
New York 8.00% Final
Alabama 7.31% Requested
Vermont 4.30% Final
Iowa 4.19% Requested
Mississippi 3.69% Requested

Source: Benefitra 2027 state funding data. Your state's figure and its five-year history are on the Benefitra health insurance funding pages.

New York and Vermont stand out for another reason. Both use pure community rating in the small group market, so there is no age step. A renewal there should sit much closer to the carrier's filed number on the effective date than it would in Texas or North Carolina. The 2027 ACA Marketplace rule affects the plans offered in 2027, and with enhanced premium tax credits ending in December 2025, smaller and higher-risk pools can push average costs up for the businesses that remain insured.

The age step every renewal includes

Small group plans are priced member by member. Under 45 CFR 147.102, the premium can vary by age up to 3:1 for adults, and "the enrollee's age as of the date of policy issuance or renewal must be used." Each employee's price is set by their age on your renewal date, and at the next renewal every employee who stays is exactly one year older. Nothing about this is uncertain. It happens at every renewal for every member who stays, unless the state bans age rating.

Most states use the federal default age curve that CMS published in December 2016. Massachusetts, Minnesota, Oregon and Utah are among the states that use their own curves. The CMS curve sets age 21 at 1.000 and age 64 at 3.000, but the steps between those ages are uneven.

Moving from age To age Price increase from the age step
24 25 0.4%
27 28 3.7%
35 36 0.7%
40 41 1.9%
45 46 3.9%
50 51 4.4%
55 56 4.6%
58 59 2.2%
60 61 3.5%
63 64 1.6%
64 65 and up 0%

Calculated from the CMS federal default standard age curve.

The steepest part of the curve runs from 45 to 58, where almost every birthday adds 4% to 5%. A workforce clustered in its late 40s and 50s pays the most for simply staying together. We covered the other end of the curve, employees who pass 64 and stop stepping up, in what employees over 65 cost a small group plan in 2027.

How much age adds for three real-world group shapes

To see what this does to a whole group, we ran three 10-employee groups through the federal curve. All three keep the same people with employee-only coverage, and each member moves up one year.

Group Employee ages Age step added to the renewal
Younger crew 24, 26, 27, 29, 31, 33, 35, 38, 41, 44 1.85%
Mixed office 24, 29, 33, 38, 41, 45, 49, 52, 57, 61 2.92%
Long-tenured shop 44, 47, 49, 51, 53, 55, 56, 58, 60, 62 3.85%

The age step multiplies with the filed change rather than adding to it, and if the employer pays a fixed share of the premium, it also raises the group’s total contribution amount. A mixed office facing the 12.8% median gets 1.128 × 1.0292, or a 16.1% increase before anything else changes. The long-tenured shop gets 17.1% from the same filing. An owner who is told "the state approved 12.8%" and then sees 16% or 17% has not been singled out.

Small business team with employees of different ages, whose birthdays move them up the 2027 small group age curve

Plan mapping and changes to cost sharing

The second item is the plan itself. When a carrier retires a plan, it can move your group into a replacement plan. If the carrier is discontinuing the whole product, 45 CFR 147.106 requires written notice at least 90 calendar days before coverage ends. Carriers can also change a plan without calling it a discontinuation, as long as the change is a "uniform modification." Among other conditions, the plan keeps the same cost-sharing structure "except for any variation in cost sharing solely related to changes in cost and utilization of medical care, or to maintain the same metal tier level."

In practice that means a higher deductible or copay at renewal as part of the plan design, made so the plan stays inside its metal tier. Rhode Island's summary notes that its averages already include benefit changes and plans "terminated and mapped to existing plan offerings." The average does not tell you which direction your plan went. Kaiser's Georgia filing alone shows a spread of 1.8 points between its lowest and highest plan increase.

Check your current plan against the renewal exhibit. Is the plan ID the same as last year? Did the deductible, out-of-pocket maximum or drug tiers change? A plan with lower premiums may still come with a higher deductible. Compare total costs, not just the monthly premium, when a mapped or modified plan changes cost sharing. If either answer is yes, the renewal is pricing a different product than the one you bought.

Why the renewal month changes the price

Small group carriers can update rates every quarter. Under 45 CFR 156.80, changes "must have effective dates of January 1, April 1, July 1, or October 1," and the rate you lock in "will apply for the entire plan year of the group health plan."

Rhode Island publishes the quarterly projection factors each carrier requested for 2027. A group renewing in April pays 2.0% to 3.0% more than an identical group renewing in January. A group renewing in October pays 6.2% to 9.2% more. The commissioner's explanation is simple: a group renewing later has more months of health care cost trend, and then more months of medical inflation, built into a rate it will hold for a full year.

For a January 1 renewal, the quarterly factor mostly washes out, because you are comparing a first quarter 2027 rate with the first quarter 2026 rate you paid. Kaiser's Georgia memorandum says its increase "is calculated relative to first quarter 2026 rates." Groups that renew in April, July or October should expect their renewal to differ from the annual headline by that quarter's factor.

A worked example for a 10-employee group

Take the mixed office from the table above. It pays $8,000 a month in 2026 and renews January 1 with a carrier that filed close to the 12.8% median.

Step Monthly premium Change from 2026
2026 premium $8,000
Apply the filed 12.8% $9,024 +12.8%
Add the age step (2.92%) $9,288 +16.1%
Carrier maps the group to a plan priced 3% higher $9,566 +19.6%

The age step alone costs this employer about $3,162 more a year than the headline suggests. Being moved to a more expensive replacement plan creates a higher premium and brings the annual increase to about $18,794. None of that comes from claims. The 3% mapping figure is an illustration, so use the plan-level factor in your own carrier's filing.

Five steps to check your own renewal season

Start reviewing your renewal at least 90 days before the renewal date.

  1. Find your carrier's filing. Search your carrier and state on ratereview.healthcare.gov or your state insurance department's rate review page. These resources provide access to the average change and plan-level details.
  2. Get the renewal by member. About 90 days before renewal, ask your broker for the rate exhibit plus your census and claims data, along with the rate exhibit that shows each enrolled member's age and premium for 2026 and 2027. Small group premiums are calculated member by member, so the carrier has these figures for every group.
  3. Strip out the age step. Price each member's 2027 rate at last year's age band using your state's curve, or use the federal curve above. What remains is the plan-level change.
  4. Compare plan to plan. Before you shop or make changes, model at least three plan design scenarios. Check that the plan ID matches, compare provider networks, and confirm that cost sharing did not move. If you were mapped, compare the new plan's filed change with your old plan's.
  5. Divide out what is left. Take your renewal, then divide by 1 plus the plan's filed change, by 1 plus the age step and by the quarter factor. If more than one or two points remain, ask the carrier to explain them in writing. Census changes, such as new hires or added dependents, are the usual answer.

The renewal stress test guide shows how to run the next two or three years through the same steps. Explain any benefit or employee contributions changes clearly to employees during open enrollment.

Employer checking a 2027 small group renewal line by line against the carrier's rate filing

When the math points you to a different funding route

Some groups find that the renewal checks out to the decimal and is still too expensive, and when the math still looks unaffordable, employers may need a different funding arrangement. That is useful information. The age step does not go away in later years. A group with most of its people in their late 40s and 50s will keep adding 3% to 4% a year from age alone on top of whatever carriers file. Benefitra's 2028 renewal forecast puts the national small group average at 10.7% for next year, with a likely range of 7.7% to 16.7%.

Level-funded plans combine features of fully insured and self-funded plans, using a different funding structure from ACA-rated small-group coverage, and pricing is based on expected future claims rather than only statewide pooled rates. Self-funded plans allow employers to pay claims directly and may offer more flexibility in plan design. In our 2027 funding simulator runs for 30-employee groups, level funding beat staying fully insured over five years in a median of 91% of simulated outcomes across 47 states. For 10-employee groups the median was 81% across 46 states. Employers typically pay a fixed monthly amount that includes expected claims, stop loss insurance, administrative fees, and other expenses, and some plans may return surplus when claims run lower than expected. Many plans also require about 10 to 15 enrolled employees. That is not a guarantee for any single group. Healthy, younger groups gain most, and a group with a known high-cost claimant may do better staying community rated. We compared the two routes in detail in level funded vs fully insured for 2027 renewals, including carrier differences and any compliance considerations tied to the new approach.

ICHRA uses a defined reimbursement so eligible employees can buy individual health coverage, and MEWAs are alternative funding arrangements worth reviewing.

If you decide to move after December 15, you have missed the window when carriers waive participation requirements and contribution minimums. Our small group special enrollment period guide explains the November 15 to December 15 rules. Funding strategies affect eligibility rules, applicable rules, and administrative requirements.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my small group premium increase higher than the rate the state approved?

The approved or filed rate is an average for members who stay the same age. Your renewal moves every employee up one year on the age curve and may price a mapped or modified plan. If you renew after January, it also includes a quarterly factor. For a January renewal, age alone usually adds 2 to 4 points.

Can a small group carrier raise my rate because of our claims?

Not under ACA small group rules. Premiums can vary only by family size, rating area, age and tobacco use, and the carrier's claims experience is pooled across its whole small group market in the state.

How much does one year of age add to a small group premium?

On the federal default curve, it ranges from 0% for adults aged 21 to 23 and members 64 and older to about 4.7% for members in their late 40s and 50s. For a typical 10-person group it works out to roughly 2% to 4% of the total premium.

Do New York and Vermont small groups get an age increase at renewal?

Both states require community rating in the small group market, so premiums do not vary by age. A renewal in those states should track the carrier's filed change more closely, apart from plan changes.

Where can I see my carrier's 2027 small group rate filing?

Most filings are posted on ratereview.healthcare.gov and on your state insurance department's site. Benefitra's state funding pages list the 2027 small group change for each state and show whether it is still requested or final. If you're comparing alternatives like ICHRA or Marketplace coverage, review how marketplace premium tax credits work, whether an offer could affect eligibility for premium tax credits, and how premiums, reimbursements, employee cost, and family coverage compare. Employers comparing other options for 2027 should also keep the IRS affordability percentage of 10.22% in mind.

Sources

  1. Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, How much and why premiums are going up for small businesses in 2027, August 6, 2026, https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/brief/how-much-and-why-premiums-are-going-up-for-small-businesses-in-2027/
  2. Rhode Island Office of the Health Insurance Commissioner, Small Employer Group Market Rate Summary, Requested 2027 Rates, June 2026, https://ohic.ri.gov/sites/g/files/xkgbur736/files/2026-06/2027%20Small%20Group%20Rate%20Review%20Detailed%20Summary.pdf
  3. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Georgia, Georgia SG 2027 ACA Actuarial Memorandum, May 26, 2026, https://ratereview.healthcare.gov/files/899427111_2027_GA_SG_Actuarial_Memorandum_05262026_Redacted.pdf
  4. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Guidance Regarding Age Curves and State Reporting, December 16, 2016, https://www.cms.gov/cciio/resources/regulations-and-guidance/downloads/final-guidance-regarding-age-curves-and-state-reporting-12-16-16.pdf
  5. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Market Rating Reforms: State Specific Rating Variations, accessed October 27, 2026, https://www.cms.gov/cciio/programs-and-initiatives/health-insurance-market-reforms/state-rating
  6. U.S. Government Publishing Office via Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 45 CFR 147.102, Fair health insurance premiums, current as of October 2026, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/147.102
  7. U.S. Government Publishing Office via Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 45 CFR 147.106, Guaranteed renewability of coverage, current as of October 2026, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/147.106
  8. U.S. Government Publishing Office via Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, 45 CFR 156.80, Single risk pool, current as of October 2026, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/45/156.80
  9. Benefitra, 2027 state health insurance funding analysis (small group filed and final rates, funding simulator results), accessed October 27, 2026, https://benefitra.com/health-insurance-funding/
Sam Newland, CFP®

About the Author

Sam Newland, CFP® is the Founder and President of Benefitra. With 13+ years in the employee benefits industry and a background as a nationally recognized benefits advisor, Sam specializes in helping mid-size employers identify the funding strategies, plan structures, and tax optimization approaches that reduce costs without cutting coverage. He can be reached at sam@benefitra.com.

Related Benefitra Tools